Cookie Plug
3.92/5.0
3/5.0
14, Jan 2025
Just Okay
They weren?t terrible, but they weren?t great either. The cookies are massive, which is fun, but I didn?t think the flavor matched the size. They were very sweet and a little greasy. Overall, just okay, but not worth the premium price tag for me.
2/5.0
08, Jan 2025
Dry and Overbaked
My cookies weren?t as soft as I expected. A couple of them were actually pretty dry, almost like they?d been sitting too long. The flavors were fine, but nothing memorable. For the price, I expected a fresh, bakery-quality cookie. Unfortunately, that wasn?t what I got.
3/5.0
03, Jan 2025
Too Gimmicky
I feel like The Cookie Plug is more about branding than actual quality. The names and packaging are cool, but the cookies didn?t back it up. They were average at best and way too sweet for me. I?d rather stick to classic homemade cookies.
5/5.0
28, Dec 2024
Definitely Ordering Again
After trying The Cookie Plug, I know I?ll be ordering again. The cookies were flavorful, chewy, and much larger than I expected. They felt indulgent without being too heavy, and the variety kept things interesting. The packaging looked great, and everything arrived in perfect condition. I shared a few with friends, and they were just as impressed as I was. It?s nice to find a dessert option that feels different from the usual. Definitely one of my favorites.
4/5.0
23, Dec 2024
Fun Dessert Experience
The Cookie Plug is more than just a box of cookies, it feels like a whole dessert experience. The names, the packaging, and the cookie sizes all make it stand out. The flavors were tasty, though a couple leaned too sweet for my preference. Still, the overall quality was good, and they stayed fresh for days. I think they work best as a fun indulgence or for sharing at a party. A unique take on cookies that?s worth trying.
5/5.0
17, Dec 2024
Memorable Treat
These cookies made a lasting impression. From the fun packaging to the bold flavors, everything about the order felt special. They?re large enough that one was more than enough for dessert, but that didn?t stop me from trying a couple in one sitting. The freshness was great, and the quality felt consistent. I enjoyed the variety, and it was fun to sample them with friends. They?re definitely a memorable treat I?d happily order again in the future.
3/5.0
12, Dec 2024
Overpriced Treat
The Cookie Plug cookies are good but honestly overpriced for what you get. They?re large, but the flavor didn?t feel that special to me. I?ve had better cookies locally at a much lower cost. Fun concept, but I probably wouldn?t order them again.
2/5.0
06, Dec 2024
Shipping Issues
My order took longer than expected, and when it finally arrived, a few cookies were broken. The flavors were decent, but the freshness wasn?t what I was hoping for. For the price, I expected more care in delivery. Disappointing experience overall, especially for the hype.
2/5.0
01, Dec 2024
Too Sweet for Me
The cookies looked great, but they were way too sweet for my taste. I could barely finish one without feeling overwhelmed. They?re also pretty heavy, which makes it hard to enjoy more than a bite or two. Not terrible, but not something I?d buy again.
5/5.0
25, Nov 2024
Great Surprise
I wasn?t sure what to expect, but The Cookie Plug ended up being a wonderful surprise. The cookies were big, flavorful, and fresh. The branding was fun, and the names made me laugh. They were packaged well and arrived quickly. I shared them with my roommates, and we all agreed they were delicious. They?re richer than typical cookies, but that?s part of what makes them stand out. I?ll definitely be ordering again for another fun treat.
5/5.0
20, Nov 2024
Outstanding Flavor
I loved how much flavor these cookies packed into every bite. They weren?t just sweet, they had a depth of taste that made them stand out. The texture was soft and chewy, and the portion sizes were very generous. They arrived fresh, and the packaging kept them looking perfect. I enjoyed trying different flavors and sharing a few with family. It felt like a dessert that had been carefully made, not just mass-produced. A really enjoyable experience overall.
4/5.0
14, Nov 2024
Fun to Share
These cookies were a fun experience to share with friends. Everyone was impressed by the size and presentation. The flavors were tasty, though a couple were sweeter than I prefer. Still, they were enjoyable overall. I liked how soft and chewy they were, and they stayed fresh for a few days. They?re a little more expensive, but it feels like you?re buying an experience as much as a dessert. Definitely something I?d consider getting again for gatherings.
5/5.0
09, Nov 2024
Reliable Quality
I?ve placed a few orders now, and each time the cookies have been consistently fresh and delicious. I like knowing I can count on the quality being the same. The flavors are bold, and the portion sizes are generous. They?re soft but hold together well, which makes them enjoyable to eat. The packaging always keeps them secure during shipping, so they arrive in perfect condition. It?s become one of my go-to places when I want a special dessert.
5/5.0
03, Nov 2024
Worth the Hype
I?d seen people talk about The Cookie Plug online, and I was curious to try them myself. They really lived up to the hype. The cookies were fresh, rich, and full of flavor. I liked the chewy texture and the variety in the box I ordered. They?re large enough to share, though I ended up keeping most for myself. The packaging and presentation made the whole thing feel fun. I?d recommend them for anyone who loves bold desserts.
3/5.0
29, Oct 2024
Heavy but Lacking Flavor
The cookies were definitely big, but they didn?t taste as good as they looked. The texture was dense, and some flavors seemed one-note. I expected something more creative and flavorful. Overall, it just didn?t justify the hype or the cost for me.
2/5.0
23, Oct 2024
Packaging Could Be Better
My cookies arrived in a box that wasn?t very secure, and a couple were squished. The flavors were okay, but the presentation made it feel cheap. For something this pricey, I was hoping for a more polished experience. Probably won?t reorder anytime soon.
2/5.0
18, Oct 2024
Not Worth the Calories
These cookies are massive and super rich, but they didn?t have the flavor payoff I expected. They felt more like sugar bombs than well-balanced desserts. I had one and felt done. If you like very sweet desserts, maybe, but they weren?t for me.
4/5.0
12, Oct 2024
Bigger Than Expected
When the box arrived, I was shocked at how big the cookies were. They?re more like mini cakes than cookies, which was a fun surprise. The flavors were enjoyable, with a few standing out more than others. They were soft and moist, even after a couple of days. I think they?re best when shared since they?re so filling. Overall, I?d say The Cookie Plug is a unique dessert option that?s worth trying at least once for the experience.
5/5.0
07, Oct 2024
Sweet Indulgence
These cookies are pure indulgence, and I loved every bite. They were larger than expected, soft in the center, and flavorful throughout. The presentation felt special, almost like opening a gift. My family and I enjoyed sampling the different varieties, and it turned into a fun experience. They?re not the kind of cookies you eat casually every day, but when you want a dessert that stands out, they?re perfect. I?ll definitely be ordering them again for future celebrations.
5/5.0
01, Oct 2024
Cookies with Character
What I enjoyed most about The Cookie Plug is how much character the cookies have. The names are clever, the branding is fun, and the cookies themselves live up to the hype. They?re thick, chewy, and packed with flavor. My personal favorite was the chocolate-heavy one, it was indulgent without being overwhelming. The size makes them feel like a special dessert, and the whole experience from ordering to delivery was smooth. It?s a creative concept done really well.
5/5.0
26, Sep 2024
Perfectly Packaged
I really appreciated the effort The Cookie Plug puts into packaging. The cookies arrived neatly arranged and completely intact. They were fresh and soft, almost like they?d just been baked. I enjoyed trying different flavors, and each one felt like its own little dessert. They?re filling, so one cookie is plenty for me at a time. These make a fun treat for family nights or to share with friends. Definitely something I?d consider ordering again for future occasions.
4/5.0
20, Sep 2024
Fun Twist on Cookies
These cookies put a fun twist on the traditional cookie experience. The branding is eye-catching, the names are creative, and the cookies themselves are impressive in both size and flavor. Some were sweeter than I normally like, but the overall taste was good. They work best when shared since they?re so large. Delivery was smooth, and the packaging was solid. I?d recommend them to anyone looking for something a little out of the ordinary in their dessert options.
5/5.0
15, Sep 2024
Delicious and Memorable
The Cookie Plug has quickly become one of my favorite indulgences. The cookies are bold, flavorful, and unforgettable. I loved the unique packaging, which made opening the box exciting. The cookies themselves were soft, rich, and perfectly balanced. The chocolate-based flavors were especially good. They lasted a few days without losing freshness, which made them easy to enjoy over time. They?re pricier than typical cookies, but the size and taste make them worth it. A truly memorable dessert experience.
Nicole Sanders
2/5.0
09, Sep 2024
Not for Everyone
The concept is fun, but the cookies themselves didn?t impress me. They were overly sweet, and the texture wasn?t as soft as I?d hoped. My kids liked them, but for me, they felt like a sugar overload. Definitely not something I?d buy again.
Daniel White
2/5.0
04, Sep 2024
Shipping Delay
My cookies arrived later than expected, and by then they didn?t feel very fresh. The flavors were just okay, but the dryness took away from the experience. For something advertised as premium, I thought the quality control would be better. Overall, a letdown.
Harper Reed
3/5.0
29, Aug 2024
Average at Best
Honestly, I wasn?t impressed. The cookies were fine, but nothing special. They didn?t feel fresh, and some flavors tasted artificial. For the price, I thought I?d be wowed, but instead, they felt like oversized regular cookies. Probably not worth ordering again for me.
Oliver Perez
5/5.0
24, Aug 2024
Perfect for Parties
I bought a box of cookies for a small get-together, and they were the highlight of the night. Everyone loved the size and the creative names. The flavors were fun, and the texture was perfectly soft and chewy. They also looked great displayed on the table, which added to the experience. These aren?t your average cookies, they feel more like a dessert centerpiece. I?d definitely order again for another party, because they left a strong impression on my guests.
Olivia Parker
4/5.0
18, Aug 2024
Fresh and Flavorful
My order from The Cookie Plug arrived earlier than expected, and everything was fresh. The cookies were much bigger than I anticipated, which was a nice surprise. I liked the different flavor options, and while some were a bit sweeter than my usual preference, they were still delicious. The presentation makes them feel special, and they?re fun to share with friends or family. I think they work best for occasions when you want something a little extra indulgent.
Mia Evans
5/5.0
13, Aug 2024
Impressive Quality
These cookies were impressive from the first bite. They?re thick, chewy, and filled with flavor. I especially liked the chocolate chip variety, which had the perfect balance of sweetness and richness. The portion sizes are big enough to feel indulgent, and they stayed fresh for days. I?ve tried other online cookie companies, but this one stands out for both quality and creativity. The packaging was secure, and delivery was quick. Overall, it was a smooth and enjoyable experience.
Benjamin Lee
5/5.0
07, Aug 2024
Great Gift Idea
I decided to send a box of The Cookie Plug to my cousin as a birthday gift, and it was a huge hit. They loved the packaging, the unique cookie names, and of course, the taste. I ended up trying a few myself when visiting, and I can confirm they?re as good as described. The cookies are dense, rich, and very satisfying. I think they make an excellent gift for someone who enjoys desserts. Definitely an experience worth sharing with others.
Ava Clark
4/5.0
01, Aug 2024
Fun and Tasty
I ordered a mixed box, and it turned out to be a great choice. The cookies are larger than expected, and each one tasted freshly made. Some flavors stood out more than others, but overall they were really good. I liked that they weren?t overly dry or crumbly. The branding is fun and adds to the overall experience. I think they?re a little more expensive than typical cookies, but you?re paying for something unique. A fun treat I?d gladly order again.
Owen Brooks
5/5.0
27, Jul 2024
Unique Cookie Experience
The Cookie Plug really surprised me. The branding caught my attention first, but once I tried the cookies, I was hooked. They?re big, flavorful, and full of personality. Each flavor has its own character, and I enjoyed trying different ones. The packaging kept them fresh and intact during shipping, which I appreciated. They?re rich enough that one cookie feels like a full dessert. It?s not something I?d eat every day, but when I want something special, this is a perfect option.
Grace Mitchell
5/5.0
21, Jul 2024
Always Satisfying
Every time I order from The Cookie Plug, I?m satisfied. The cookies are big, tasty, and always fresh. I enjoy trying different flavors, and they never disappoint. It?s a brand I trust now when I want to treat myself. Excellent quality and great service overall.
Henry Scott
2/5.0
16, Jul 2024
Messy and Overwhelming
The cookies arrived fine, but eating them was another story. They?re huge, crumbly, and overwhelmingly sweet. I ended up throwing some away because I just couldn?t finish them. I like desserts, but this was just too much without enough flavor balance to make it enjoyable.
Nathan Diaz
3/5.0
10, Jul 2024
Expected More
I?d seen a lot of hype online, so I had high expectations. Unfortunately, the cookies didn?t live up to it. They were heavy, too sweet, and kind of greasy. The size is impressive, but the taste wasn?t. It felt like style over substance.
Emily Foster
2/5.0
05, Jul 2024
Too Rich and Dense
These cookies are massive, but for me, that wasn?t a good thing. They were so dense and sweet that I couldn?t enjoy them. I had to cut one into pieces just to manage a bite. The branding is fun, but the taste wasn?t great.
Brandon Lewis
5/5.0
29, Jun 2024
Amazing Cookies
These cookies were amazing from start to finish. They arrived fresh, tasted fantastic, and the portions were generous. I really liked the mix of flavors and how each one felt unique. The quality was great, and it?s clear they put effort into their product. Highly recommend.
Chloe Wright
4/5.0
24, Jun 2024
Nice Treat
The Cookie Plug delivered a nice treat. The cookies were large, chewy, and flavorful. Some flavors were stronger than others, but overall they were enjoyable. I wouldn?t eat them all the time, but for an occasional indulgence they hit the spot. A fun experience.
Jack Lopez
5/5.0
18, Jun 2024
Better Than Expected
I wasn?t sure what to expect, but these cookies were even better than I thought they?d be. They were thick, soft, and packed with flavor. The packaging kept them fresh, and the delivery was smooth. A really nice surprise, and I?ll be recommending them to friends.
Lily Brown
5/5.0
13, Jun 2024
Delicious Cookies
The cookies were delicious and worth the wait. They had a soft texture and bold flavors that stood out. I liked how different they felt from other cookies I?ve tried. They make a great indulgence when you?re looking for something unique. I?ll be ordering again soon.
Daniel Green
4/5.0
07, Jun 2024
Fun Dessert Option
These cookies were a fun dessert option to try. The size made them stand out, and the flavors were enjoyable. They?re richer than I expected, so one cookie was more than enough. Overall, it was a good experience, and I?d consider ordering again for special occasions.
Isabella Nguyen
5/5.0
02, Jun 2024
Great Quality
The quality of these cookies was evident right away. They tasted freshly baked, had a great texture, and were packed with flavor. I liked that they weren?t crumbly or dry. They felt indulgent in the best way. Definitely one of the better cookie experiences I?ve had online.
Noah Patel
5/5.0
27, May 2024
Perfect for Sharing
These cookies are so big that one was plenty to share. They were moist, flavorful, and arrived fresh. My family enjoyed them as much as I did, and it turned into a fun treat for everyone. I?ll definitely order again for family nights.
Sophia Kim
4/5.0
22, May 2024
Impressive Presentation
The packaging and branding stood out to me right away, it felt like more than just a box of cookies. The flavors were enjoyable, and the size of the cookies was impressive. A little too sweet at times, but still worth trying if you enjoy big desserts.
Lucas Thompson
5/5.0
16, May 2024
Loved Them
I absolutely loved the cookies I received. They were soft, chewy, and full of flavor. The chocolate-based ones were my favorite, but all of them were enjoyable. They came packaged well and felt fresh upon arrival. I?ll definitely be ordering again for myself and as gifts.
Jenna Ramirez
4/5.0
11, May 2024
Good Variety
The variety of cookies available made it exciting to order. Some flavors were better than others, but overall everything tasted good. The cookies are definitely oversized, so they feel like more than just a snack. I?d order again when I?m in the mood for something different.
Ryan Cooper
5/5.0
05, May 2024
A Treat Worth Having
These cookies were a real treat. They had a soft, cake-like texture and plenty of flavor. I liked how generous the portion sizes were, it really made them feel special. I?ll be saving them for when I want to spoil myself a little. Excellent experience overall.
Maya Rodriguez
5/5.0
30, Apr 2024
Consistently Good
I?ve ordered a couple of times now, and the cookies have been consistently fresh and tasty. I appreciate that the quality is reliable, and the packaging keeps them in great shape. They?re rich, indulgent, and fun to share with friends. Definitely a solid option for dessert lovers.
Ethan Liu
4/5.0
24, Apr 2024
Fun to Try
I tried The Cookie Plug for the first time, and it was definitely a fun experience. The cookies are bigger than expected, and the flavors are bold. Some were sweeter than I prefer, but overall they were enjoyable. I?d recommend trying them at least once for something different.
Olivia Harper
5/5.0
19, Apr 2024
Fast Delivery
My order shipped quickly and arrived in perfect condition. The cookies were large and soft, with a variety of flavors to enjoy. I liked how fresh they tasted even after a couple of days. Overall, it was a smooth experience, and I?ll be coming back for more.
Lauren King
5/5.0
13, Apr 2024
Sweet Indulgence
These cookies were exactly what I was hoping for, a sweet, indulgent dessert that felt special. The flavors were rich, and the texture was perfect. I especially enjoyed the chocolate chip, which was chewy and full of flavor. It?s a fun treat I?d happily order again.
Oliver Young
2/5.0
08, Apr 2024
Customer Service Lacking
When my order had an issue, I reached out to customer service but didn?t get much help. The cookies tasted fine, but the lack of support left me disappointed.
Chloe Martinez
3/5.0
02, Apr 2024
Too Dense
The cookies were very dense, making them heavy and hard to enjoy more than a bite or two. The flavor was okay, but the texture wasn?t my favorite. I prefer something lighter.
Liam Anderson
2/5.0
27, Mar 2024
Stale on Arrival
My order arrived quickly, but unfortunately, the cookies tasted stale. They weren?t soft or fresh, which was disappointing. I probably won?t order again unless freshness improves.
Hannah Brooks
4/5.0
22, Mar 2024
Pleasant Surprise
I wasn?t sure what to expect, but these cookies turned out to be really good. They were fresh, soft, and flavorful. The size was impressive, and I liked how they felt indulgent without being too over the top. A little pricey, but worth it for a treat.
Rachel Morris
5/5.0
16, Mar 2024
Great for Parties
I ordered a dozen for a small party, and they were a hit. Everyone loved the fun names and big sizes. The cookies tasted fresh and had just the right balance of chewiness and sweetness. It?s something people remember, so I?d order again for gatherings in the future.
Thomas Gray
4/5.0
11, Mar 2024
Deliciously Different
The Cookie Plug offers a different take on cookies, and I enjoyed the bold, oversized approach. The flavors were enjoyable, and the texture was satisfying. They?re more expensive than average cookies, but you?re paying for something unique. It?s not an everyday snack, but definitely worth ordering once in a while.
Sarah Collins
5/5.0
05, Mar 2024
Crowd Favorite
I brought these cookies to work, and they disappeared quickly. Everyone commented on how big and delicious they were. The variety made it easy for everyone to try something they liked, and the overall freshness was great. I think this might become my go-to for office treats.
Benjamin Diaz
5/5.0
28, Feb 2024
Cookies With Personality
These aren?t just cookies, they feel like an experience. The branding is fun, the sizes are impressive, and the taste matches the hype. I especially liked the chocolate flavors, which were rich and satisfying. It?s something different from typical desserts, and I?d gladly order again to share with others.
Sophia Ross
4/5.0
23, Feb 2024
Great Customer Service
My order arrived with everything intact, and customer service was very responsive to a question I had about flavors. The cookies themselves were big, soft, and packed with flavor. While they?re a bit on the sweet side, they were still enjoyable. A nice experience overall, and I?ll order again.
Mason Lopez
5/5.0
17, Feb 2024
Excellent Quality
The quality of these cookies impressed me. From the ingredients to the texture, everything felt top-notch. I appreciated how fresh they tasted upon arrival, and the packaging kept them safe. They make for a nice treat when you?re craving something more than the average cookie. Definitely worth ordering.
Ella Garcia
4/5.0
12, Feb 2024
Tasty but Filling
These cookies are huge, so one was more than enough for me. The flavors were rich, and the texture was soft and chewy. I enjoyed them a lot, though I couldn?t eat more than one at a time. A fun indulgence when you?re in the mood for something sweet.
Liam Kim
5/5.0
06, Feb 2024
Perfect Gift Idea
I sent a box to a friend as a gift, and they absolutely loved it. The cookies arrived quickly, packaged well, and looked just as good as they tasted. It made for a unique gift that felt thoughtful and fun. I?ll be ordering again for birthdays and holidays.
Harper Hill
3/5.0
01, Feb 2024
Limited Flavors
I expected more variety when I placed my order. The options available were fine, but nothing stood out as unique. The cookies themselves were decent, but I wanted something more exciting for the price.
Noah Bennett
2/5.0
26, Jan 2024
Overpriced
While the cookies weren?t terrible, they didn?t justify the high cost. They?re fun to try once, but I don?t see myself ordering again. The hype didn?t match the actual experience.
Lily White
3/5.0
21, Jan 2024
Heavy Cookies
These cookies are huge, which might be great for some, but I found them too dense and filling. It felt more like eating cake than a cookie. Not bad, just not enjoyable for me.
Samuel Turner
4/5.0
15, Jan 2024
Fun Experience
The Cookie Plug is a fun way to enjoy dessert. The branding, the size of the cookies, and the overall presentation made the order feel special. I liked the variety, and while some flavors stood out more than others, everything was tasty. It?s worth trying if you love cookies.
Mia Thompson
5/5.0
10, Jan 2024
Big and Flavorful
The cookies are seriously big, and that?s part of the charm. I enjoyed how soft and rich they tasted without being too overwhelming. The mix of flavors was great, and even after a couple of days they still tasted fresh. A solid choice when you want something indulgent.
Jack Edwards
5/5.0
04, Jan 2024
Great Treat for Sharing
I ordered these cookies for a family gathering, and everyone loved them. They?re thick, flavorful, and perfect for sharing. The box presentation was neat, and the variety made it easy for everyone to find a favorite. Definitely a fun alternative to regular desserts. I?ll be recommending them to friends.
Ella Wright
4/5.0
30, Dec 2023
Impressive Flavors
I really enjoyed trying The Cookie Plug for the first time. The flavors were bold, and each cookie had its own unique twist. They?re much larger than typical cookies, which made them feel like a special dessert. A little pricey, but the quality justifies it. Overall, a very good experience.
Henry Scott
5/5.0
25, Dec 2023
Fresh and Delicious
I was pleasantly surprised at how fresh the cookies tasted when they arrived. They were soft, chewy, and full of flavor. The packaging kept everything intact, and each cookie felt like a little indulgence. The portions are large, so even one cookie feels satisfying. I?ll definitely order again when I?m craving a sweet treat.
Grace Miller
2/5.0
19, Dec 2023
Inconsistent Quality
The first order I placed was great, but the second one was disappointing. Some cookies were fresh, while others tasted stale. For a company focused on premium cookies, the inconsistency was frustrating.
Adam Rivera
3/5.0
14, Dec 2023
Service Could Be Better
Customer service was slow to respond when I had a question about my order. The cookies tasted okay, but the lack of communication left me unimpressed. I expected more professionalism from the brand.
Megan Young
4/5.0
08, Dec 2023
Nice Treat
The cookies were a nice treat. I enjoyed trying a variety of flavors, and most of them were really good. Delivery was reliable, and the packaging was secure. A fun way to enjoy something sweet.
Alexander Reed
5/5.0
03, Dec 2023
Sweet and Satisfying
The Cookie Plug cookies hit the spot perfectly. They were indulgent without feeling overwhelming. The presentation was fun, and delivery was smooth. I?ll definitely be ordering again to try more flavors.
Chloe Price
2/5.0
27, Nov 2023
Not Worth the Price
For what I paid, I expected something more impressive. The cookies were thick and big, but the flavor didn?t stand out. It felt more like a novelty than a quality product. Disappointing overall.
Lucas Hill
3/5.0
22, Nov 2023
Flavor Lacked Balance
The cookies were very rich but lacked balance in flavor. The sweetness overpowered everything else. The texture was good, but I couldn?t enjoy the taste for long. They?re fun to try once, but not something I?d regularly order.
Isabella Wright
5/5.0
16, Nov 2023
Fantastic Cookies
I?m really glad I tried The Cookie Plug. The cookies were thick, chewy, and delicious. Delivery was quick, and the flavors were bold and creative. A really fun and tasty order overall.
Noah Wilson
4/5.0
11, Nov 2023
Big Cookies
The cookies are definitely bigger than most! They were soft and tasty, though I found some flavors a little too rich. Still, they were fun to try, and my family enjoyed sharing them.
Kevin Hill
5/5.0
05, Nov 2023
Fresh and Fun
The cookies were fresh, chewy, and full of flavor. I liked the playful branding too, it made the order feel like more than just cookies. Everything from delivery to taste was a great experience.
Ava Sanders
3/5.0
31, Oct 2023
Too Sweet
The cookies were decent but far too sweet for my taste. I enjoy desserts, but these felt overwhelming after just a few bites. Maybe others will like them, but I couldn?t finish one cookie without feeling it was too much.
Daniel Carter
2/5.0
25, Oct 2023
Shipping Was Slow
My cookies took much longer to arrive than expected, which made the experience frustrating. They were soft and tasty when they got here, but not as fresh as I had hoped. The delay really ruined the excitement of ordering.
Maya Patel
3/5.0
20, Oct 2023
Too Few Options
The cookies were tasty, but I found the flavor selection limited for the price point. I wanted more unique or seasonal flavors to choose from. The ones I received were okay, but nothing special. Delivery was smooth, so no complaints there, but I didn?t feel like the product lived up to the branding.
Rachel White
5/5.0
14, Oct 2023
Loved Every Bite
Every cookie in my box was amazing. The chocolate chip and birthday cake flavors were my favorites. They were thick, soft, and so satisfying. The Cookie Plug is definitely going on my list of favorite dessert places.
Anthony Johnson
4/5.0
09, Oct 2023
Very Good Cookies
I enjoyed my order a lot. The cookies were flavorful, especially the peanut butter one. Delivery was a bit slower than I hoped, but everything arrived fresh. Overall, a good experience with cookies I?d order again.
Megan Scott
5/5.0
03, Oct 2023
Excellent Quality
I was pleasantly surprised at how fresh the cookies were when they arrived. They didn?t taste mass-produced, which I appreciated. The quality was excellent, and the portion sizes were generous. Definitely satisfied my sweet cravings.
Lucas Bennett
5/5.0
28, Sep 2023
Fun and Tasty
The Cookie Plug makes cookie ordering fun. The branding, packaging, and overall vibe make it stand out. The cookies themselves are excellent, fresh and flavorful. It was a unique experience that I?d happily repeat again.
Sophia Nguyen
4/5.0
22, Sep 2023
Cookies Were Good
The cookies were really good, especially the s?mores one. They were thick and soft, which I liked. I just wish there had been more options to customize the box. Still, I was happy overall with the order.
Robert Lewis
5/5.0
16, Sep 2023
Great Customer Service
Besides the cookies being delicious, I also had a great experience with customer service. They quickly answered a question I had about shipping and were very helpful. It made the whole order feel smooth and stress-free.
Nicole Garcia
5/5.0
11, Sep 2023
Super Fresh
These cookies tasted like they had just come out of the oven. Soft, chewy, and delicious. The presentation was fun, and delivery was quick. I really enjoyed my order and will definitely be coming back for more.
Mark Evans
2/5.0
05, Sep 2023
Poor Packaging
The cookies tasted fine, but the packaging wasn?t sturdy. Several cookies arrived broken and messy, which was disappointing given the premium price. A little extra care in packaging would make a huge difference.
Laura Wilson
3/5.0
31, Aug 2023
Dry Texture
My order arrived on time, but the cookies seemed a little dry. I expected them to be more moist and chewy. They weren?t terrible, but definitely not what I was looking forward to. The taste was okay, but not memorable.
David Martinez
2/5.0
25, Aug 2023
Didn?t Live Up to Hype
I had high hopes based on the marketing and reviews, but the cookies weren?t anything special. They were thick and soft but lacked flavor. Honestly, I?ve had better cookies from local bakeries at half the price.
Ethan Robinson
4/5.0
20, Aug 2023
Unique Flavors
The Cookie Plug offers some flavors I hadn?t seen elsewhere, which made it exciting to try. The Oreo-inspired cookie was my favorite. Shipping was reliable, though I think the prices could be a little lower. Still, I?d recommend it to cookie fans.
Olivia Matthews
5/5.0
14, Aug 2023
Kids Loved Them
I ordered a box for a weekend family gathering, and the kids absolutely loved them. The cookies were soft, fun to eat, and full of flavor. Everyone wanted to know where I ordered them from. Big hit in our house!
Jessica Lee
4/5.0
09, Aug 2023
Good, but Sweet
The cookies tasted amazing, but some flavors were sweeter than I expected. Still, I really enjoyed the overall experience. The delivery was timely, and the packaging was secure. It?s definitely worth trying if you?re into unique cookie flavors.
Brian Thompson
5/5.0
03, Aug 2023
Perfect Treat
These cookies are the perfect indulgence when you?re craving something sweet. They?re thick, rich, and full of flavor. The delivery was smooth, and the box presentation was fun. I?ll be keeping The Cookie Plug in mind for future cravings.
Laura Evans
2/5.0
28, Jul 2023
Didn?t Match the Hype
I saw so many people raving about The Cookie Plug online, but when I tried them, they didn?t blow me away. The cookies were thick, sure, but they lacked the rich flavor I was expecting. They tasted more average than amazing. For the price and hype, I felt let down. Not sure I?d order again.
Anthony Walker
3/5.0
23, Jul 2023
Heavy and Overwhelming
I wanted to love these cookies, but they were just too heavy and dense for my liking. One cookie felt like a whole meal, which might be good for some people, but it wasn?t enjoyable for me. I prefer something lighter and easier to snack on. The branding is fun, but the actual eating experience wasn?t what I hoped for.
Amanda Wilson
2/5.0
17, Jul 2023
Packaging Fell Apart
While the cookies tasted decent, the packaging wasn?t sturdy enough. By the time my order arrived, a few cookies were crumbled and messy. For something branded as a premium product, I expected better. It was frustrating because the flavors seemed nice, but the presentation made it feel cheap. They should invest more in secure shipping.
Michael Davis
5/5.0
12, Jul 2023
Great Quality
The quality of these cookies really impressed me. You can tell they?re made with care, and they have that homemade feel. The double chocolate was my personal favorite. Definitely something I?ll order again for myself or as a gift.
Rebecca Allen
4/5.0
06, Jul 2023
Tasty but Heavy
The cookies were super tasty, but they are definitely on the heavy side. Just one was more than enough for me. Great flavor combinations and freshness, though I?d recommend splitting them if you don?t have a big sweet tooth.
Heather Wood
5/5.0
01, Jul 2023
Worth the Hype
I?d seen people talking about The Cookie Plug and decided to give them a try. They didn?t disappoint. The cookies were massive, flavorful, and satisfying. Definitely worth the hype, and I?ll be back to try new flavors soon.
Eric Murphy
5/5.0
25, Jun 2023
Great Experience
From ordering online to delivery, everything was smooth. The cookies arrived on time, well-packaged, and full of flavor. I loved how soft and chewy they were. It felt like getting bakery-quality cookies delivered to my door. A great overall experience.
Megan Cox
4/5.0
20, Jun 2023
Really Good Cookies
I enjoyed the cookies overall. The chocolate chip and Oreo-inspired flavors were my top picks. They were fresh and soft, though I personally prefer slightly crispier edges. Still, it was a fun and tasty order that I?d recommend to others.
Emily Richardson
5/5.0
14, Jun 2023
Family Favorite
Our family devoured the box in just a couple of days. Each cookie was big enough to share, but most of us wanted one to ourselves. Fresh, flavorful, and well-made?definitely one of the best cookie brands we?ve tried.
Mark Johnson
3/5.0
09, Jun 2023
Inconsistent Quality
I?ve ordered twice now, and the first time the cookies were fantastic, fresh, chewy, and flavorful. The second order, however, was a letdown. Some cookies were dry, and others had an off taste, almost stale. It?s frustrating when the quality isn?t consistent, especially at this price point. I really wanted to love them, but inconsistency makes me hesitant to reorder.
Jessica Parker
2/5.0
03, Jun 2023
Poor Communication
My order was delayed, and I never received a clear update from customer service. I had to send multiple emails before I got a vague response. The cookies themselves were fine, soft and sweet, but the lack of communication really soured the experience. A company that charges this much should do better at keeping customers informed about their orders.
Jonathan Rivera
4/5.0
30, May 2023
Great Taste, Took Time
The cookies tasted fantastic, and I especially enjoyed the birthday cake flavor. They were fresh and chewy. My only issue was that delivery took a bit longer than expected, but once I received them, they were definitely worth the wait.
Sarah Garcia
5/5.0
24, May 2023
Fun Packaging
Beyond the taste, I loved the creative packaging. It gave the cookies a cool vibe, and it matched the brand?s style perfectly. The cookies were delicious, and the packaging made the whole order feel even more special. Very happy with the purchase.
Brian Mitchell
3/5.0
18, May 2023
Expected More Freshness
The cookies were okay, but I was expecting them to taste freshly baked. They had a good texture, but something about the flavor felt a little flat, like they had been sitting for a while. Delivery was on time, but the actual taste didn?t live up to my expectations. They weren?t bad, just not memorable enough for the price.
Nicole Ward
5/5.0
13, May 2023
Perfect Late-Night Snack
I ordered a dozen cookies, and they arrived quickly. I was surprised at how fresh and soft they were. Great portion sizes too. They made for the perfect late-night snack with milk. I?ll definitely be ordering again soon.
Daniel Wright
4/5.0
07, May 2023
Thick and Chewy
These cookies are much thicker than regular ones, which makes them feel more indulgent. The peanut butter flavor stood out the most for me. Shipping was quick, but I wish the box had included a flavor guide. Overall, very happy with the experience.
Rachel Kelly
5/5.0
01, May 2023
Great Gift Option
I sent a cookie box to my sister for her birthday, and she absolutely loved it. She said the cookies were fresh and delicious, and the box presentation made it feel special. A wonderful gift idea for anyone who loves sweets.
Sarah Brown
2/5.0
28, Apr 2023
Not Worth the Price
Honestly, I felt the cookies were overpriced for what I received. They were thick and unique, but the flavor didn?t stand out enough to justify the cost. I?ve had local bakeries that taste fresher for a fraction of the price. Packaging was cool, but I don?t think that makes up for the overall value. Disappointed considering how much hype there was surrounding the brand.
James Miller
3/5.0
23, Apr 2023
Too Sweet for My Taste
The cookies looked amazing when they arrived, but I found most of the flavors overwhelmingly sweet. Even the chocolate chip was heavier than I expected. They?re large and fun, but I couldn?t eat more than a few bites without feeling it was too much. Maybe it?s just personal preference, but I wish there was a lighter option on the menu. Presentation was great though, so not a complete letdown.
Steven Hernandez
2/5.0
19, Apr 2023
Delivery Took Too Long
I was really excited to try The Cookie Plug after hearing good things, but my order took almost two weeks to arrive. When the box finally came, the cookies were still soft, but not as fresh as I expected. The flavors were good, but the shipping delay made the overall experience disappointing. If they improved delivery times, I?d consider ordering again, but for now, it left me frustrated.
Lisa Lee
5/5.0
12, Apr 2023
Amazing Variety
I love that The Cookie Plug offers so many different flavors. My kids had fun picking their favorites, and everyone enjoyed something different. The cookies arrived in perfect condition and tasted freshly baked. A fun and tasty experience for cookie lovers!
Matthew Lewis
4/5.0
05, Apr 2023
Good Cookies, Slightly Pricey
I really enjoyed the cookies, especially the chocolate chip. They were thick and rich, but I did find them a little on the expensive side for the quantity. Still, the quality and taste made it worth trying, and I?ll probably order again.
Emily Foster
5/5.0
02, Apr 2023
Fresh and Delicious
The cookies from The Cookie Plug are so soft and flavorful. I ordered a mixed box, and every flavor was unique and tasty. The packaging kept everything fresh, and delivery was on time. Definitely a fun treat to share with friends and family.
Cookie Plug
Address
San Antonio, United States
Website
thecookieplug.com
Email
feedback@cookieplugsatx.com
Telephone
