img

Mr. Steak

img 1/5.0

Write a review
mrsteak.com
Visit this website
194 reviews found
img 5/5.0 01, Nov 2024

Delivered Just in Time for Celebration

Ordered a box for our anniversary dinner and it arrived on time. The filets were a big hit, and the whole process was flawless. Fantastic presentation and flavor. Will use again for special occasions.

img 3/5.0 29, Oct 2024

Mediocre Experience

Hoped for more based on the reviews. The steaks were not bad, but rather average. Could be worth another try with a different cut, but not completely convinced.

img 5/5.0 26, Oct 2024

Everything Tasted Fantastic

Tried a few different cuts and enjoyed them all. The flat iron steak was particularly tender. Even the burgers were gourmet-caliber. Good investment for steak enthusiasts.

img 4/5.0 23, Oct 2024

Overall Good, One Small Issue

Meat quality was satisfactory, and shipping was timely. One of the vacuum seals had been compromised, so I used that steak first. The taste was good, but the seal malfunction made me slightly less confident.

img 5/5.0 20, Oct 2024

Cooked Up Perfectly on the Grill

Took their recipe directions and the steak came out ideal. Amazing how much improved this is compared to mass-market meat. Packing and shipping were great too.

img 2/5.0 17, Oct 2024

More Fat Than Meat

Received two ribeyes that were virtually all fat and gristle. It was a pain to cook them because so much had to be trimmed away. The result wasn't even worth the bother. Likely won't reorder this cut.

img 4/5.0 14, Oct 2024

High-End Steaks at Home

Grilled the strip steaks over the weekend and was thoroughly impressed. Tender, well-flavored, and evenly cooked. Only drawback is they were a little salty for my taste?but still really good.

img 5/5.0 11, Oct 2024

Worth the Price Tag

The meat is certainly on the higher end, but after tasting the filets and brisket burgers, it's understandable. All had excellent taste and texture. Will be ordering a second time soon.

img 3/5.0 08, Oct 2024

A Mixed Experience

The burgers were excellent, but the ribeyes were unevenly cut and tough in places. Shipping was fast, and everything arrived cold, but the steak quality varied too much to justify a five-star rating.

img 5/5.0 05, Oct 2024

Loved Every Bite

Cooked the filet mignon and couldn?t believe how tender and flavorful it was. Best steak I?ve had at home. It made for a really special dinner. Already looking forward to my next box.

img 1/5.0 02, Oct 2024

Didn?t Match the Hype

Heard a lot of good things about this brand, but my experience didn?t reflect that. The meat was tough and lacked flavor. Maybe it was just a bad batch, but not sure I?ll give it another try.

img 4/5.0 29, Sep 2024

Would Love a Smaller Portion Option

The steaks are large and thick, which is great for some, but I?d appreciate a smaller portion option for solo dinners. Quality was top-notch, just a bit too much for me.

img 5/5.0 26, Sep 2024

Delicious Meat and Helpful Team

Had a minor problem with my delivery address and customer service resolved it promptly. The steaks came on time and tasted great. Everyone at dinner was impressed.

img 2/5.0 23, Sep 2024

Not What I Expected

The filets came well-packed, but the flavor and tenderness were not up to par. Not bad, but not worth the higher price in my opinion. Perhaps just not the right cut for me.

img 4/5.0 20, Sep 2024

Great Value for Bulk Purchase

Bought a big bundle on sale. Came in frozen, nicely labeled, and portioned appropriately. Two of the steaks had too much gristle, but overall still good and worth the cost.

img 5/5.0 17, Sep 2024

Cooked Perfectly on Cast Iron

Tested their NY strip steaks on a cast iron skillet and the outcome was great. Deep flavor, excellent sear, and juicy middle. Enjoyed the quality and packaging. Will be purchasing again soon.

img 3/5.0 14, Sep 2024

Shipping Issues Affected Experience

The steaks arrived late due to a courier issue. When they showed up, the ice packs were melted, and one package was leaking. Customer service offered a partial credit, but the experience left me unsure about ordering again.

img 5/5.0 11, Sep 2024

Repeat Customer for a Reason

This is my third purchase, and it's always great. The taste, packaging, and customer service are all excellent. It's a trusted source when I feel like indulging in a steakhouse-quality meal at home.

img 4/5.0 08, Sep 2024

Happy with the Filets

Ordered two prime filets and they were great. Great texture and taste. The only reason for four stars is that they were a bit smaller than anticipated. Still tasted great though.

img 5/5.0 05, Sep 2024

Hassle-Free Gift with Great Taste

Sent a box to my in-laws as a thank you present, and they were overjoyed. They said everything tasted so fresh and enjoyed the variety. It's a wonderful alternative to gifts, and delivery was prompt.

img 2/5.0 02, Sep 2024

Inconsistent Quality Between Cuts

The ribeye was tender and juicy, but the sirloin was tough and bland. They were cooked the same, so I was really surprised at the difference. Probably won't order again unless they get more consistent.

img 3/5.0 30, Aug 2024

Slightly Overhyped

The meat was good, but not as great as some of the hype indicated. Packaging and shipping were done well, and customer service was courteous. Just wasn't the "wow" that I hoped for.

img 5/5.0 27, Aug 2024

Big Hit at the Cookout

Ordered a steak bundle for a family barbecue. Everyone loved the flavor, and it cooked evenly on charcoal. The burgers were equally as good. A good choice for having guests over.

img 4/5.0 24, Aug 2024

Solid Steaks, Could Use Less Fat

The ribeyes tasted rich, but one of them was very fatty. It still cooked fine, but pre-trimming would've been beneficial. The rest of the order was as expected and good value in general.

img 5/5.0 21, Aug 2024

Impressed by Quality and Speed

The steaks came frozen solid and were packaged well. We grilled the NY strips and were extremely impressed with how juicy and flavorful they were. It was like having a high-end restaurant experience at home. Will definitely try other cuts in future orders.

img 5/5.0 18, Aug 2024

Tastes Like a Steakhouse at Home

Grilled the ribeyes over the weekend, and they tasted just like a high-end steakhouse. Meat quality really makes a difference. Fast shipping and nice presentation, too.

img 4/5.0 15, Aug 2024

Mostly Good, One Packaging Slip

Most of the steaks arrived in good condition, but one had a loose seal. Customer service apologized and offered a discount on the next order. Appreciate the response and will try again.

img 5/5.0 12, Aug 2024

Excellent Filet for a Weeknight Treat

Cooked the filet mignon on a Tuesday night and felt like a king. Incredibly tender and full of flavor. Made an ordinary evening feel special.

img 1/5.0 09, Aug 2024

Tough and Lacked Flavor

The steaks were hard to chew and lacked the flavor I expected based on the descriptions. May have received a bad batch, but I won?t be placing another order.

img 5/5.0 06, Aug 2024

Grill Marks and Smiles All Around

Used the steaks for a backyard gathering and they were a huge hit. Everyone commented on how flavorful they were. Very satisfied with the purchase. Will definitely order again.

img 3/5.0 03, Aug 2024

OK for the Price

The meat was decent for the price, though not significantly better than high-end butcher shops nearby. Worth trying but may not be a regular purchase for me.

img 4/5.0 31, Jul 2024

Good Quality, Just Watch Shipping

Great steaks, but FedEx left the box outside too long and it was partially thawed. Not Mr. Steak's fault, but it made me nervous. Meat was still cold, and nothing spoiled, thankfully.

img 2/5.0 28, Jul 2024

Grill Needs a Redesign

Bought their infrared grill but had issues with grease fires. The burners worked well, but the grease channels seemed flawed. Wouldn't purchase the grill again, though the steaks themselves are good.

img 5/5.0 25, Jul 2024

My Freezer Is Now Fully Stocked

Took advantage of a bundle sale and stocked up. Great value for the quality. Everything arrived still frozen and neatly packed. Have already grilled three cuts and all were excellent.

img 4/5.0 22, Jul 2024

Almost Perfect Steaks

Enjoyed the steaks overall. One filet had a slight freezer burn spot, but it didn?t impact the taste too much. Everything else was flavorful and cooked up great.

img 5/5.0 19, Jul 2024

Finally Steak Worth Ordering Online

Tried a few online meat companies, and this one nailed it. The flavor and tenderness of the ribeye were top-notch. Delivery was also on point. Easy to recommend for any steak lover.

img 3/5.0 16, Jul 2024

Mixed Feelings About the Cuts

Some steaks were wonderful while others tasted somewhat average. The strip steak was very juicy, but the flat iron tasted bland. Maybe it was the batch.

img 5/5.0 13, Jul 2024

Gifting Made Easy and Delicious

Purchased as a gift and it was a success. The recipient appreciated the quality and presentation. Makes an excellent substitute for the typical holiday gift baskets. Will use again.

img 4/5.0 10, Jul 2024

Good Packaging, But Fatty Meat

Steaks were nicely packaged and shipped frozen. Appeared good all around, but one of the ribeyes had more fat than I anticipated. Still delicious, but not as lean as I had hoped.

img 5/5.0 07, Jul 2024

Great Customer Service Follow-Up

Had an inquiry regarding my order and got a quick, responsive answer. Steaks appeared excellent and arrived as promised. Not cooked them yet but feel optimistic based on the service.

img 2/5.0 04, Jul 2024

Grill Design Could Be Safer

Purchased one of the grills and encountered grease fire problems. The fat filled deflector trays and gave me flare-ups. Had to char the food. Good idea, but could use some better execution.

img 5/5.0 01, Jul 2024

Quality Matches Midwest Standards

Grew up consuming Nebraska beef, and this one is close enough. The marbling was just perfect, and the taste is reminiscent of home. Shipping out to California was fast and packaging was good.

img 4/5.0 28, Jun 2024

Filets Were Great but Huge

The filets tasted great but were far too large for an individual serving. Will order the smaller portion next time to have more control over cooking.

img 5/5.0 25, Jun 2024

So Good We Sent a Gift Back

Received a box as a gift during Christmas and enjoyed it so much that we reshipped one to the initial sender. The beef was really tender and juicy. We felt like eating out at home.

img 5/5.0 22, Jun 2024

Starter Box Was a Win

Purchased the starter box and was pleased with the selection. Ribeyes and brisket burgers were the standout. Enjoyed that everything arrived frozen and safely packaged. Will be ordering a repeat.

img 5/5.0 19, Jun 2024

Top-Tier Meat Quality

The quality of these steaks is exceptional. They're rich and significantly better than anything from the supermarket. Simple to prepare and produce consistent results each time.

img 5/5.0 16, Jun 2024

Perfect for Special Grilling Nights

The prime filets came through fast and were some of the best we've ever grilled. Juicy and flavorful. They made our Saturday night dinner restaurant quality. Definitely going to order again.

img 1/5.0 13, Jun 2024

First Order Missed the Mark

Tried Mr. Steak for the first time and was actually disappointed. All three cuts that I ordered were not enjoyable. Filets tasted bland, and the other two steaks tasted tough. Had higher hopes.

img 5/5.0 10, Jun 2024

Best Mail-Order Steak Yet

Previously tried a number of mail-order meat businesses, but Mr. Steak was a cut above. Steaks were fresh, nicely trimmed, and had excellent flavor. This will be my standard for meat delivery going forward.

img 5/5.0 07, Jun 2024

Finally Found the Right Flavor

Had been looking for steaks comparable to the best steakhouses. These were close. Kansas City cut was nice and juicy. Also enjoyed the environmentally friendly packaging. Will experiment with other cuts in the next order.

img 4/5.0 04, Jun 2024

Delicious but Uneven Ribeye

The ribeye steak had excellent flavor, but one end was much thinner than the other, making it difficult to cook evenly. Still enjoyed the meal, just needed more attention during grilling.

img 3/5.0 01, Jun 2024

Great Steaks, Poor Packaging

The meat quality was good, but packaging had issues. Ice packs melted during delivery, causing some of the vacuum seals to come loose. Had to repackage the meat upon arrival. Still enjoyed the steaks, but expected better shipping standards.

img 5/5.0 29, May 2024

Variety and Taste Surprised Us

Tried the sample box upon hearing about it online. Came with burgers, filets, strip steaks, and ribeye. Every cut cooked exceptionally well, particularly the filet?it was extremely tender. Burgers were a success as well. Quick shipping and excellent packaging.

img 5/5.0 26, May 2024

Family Loved the Porterhouse

Bought two 24 oz. Porterhouse steaks for a special family dinner. Came on time, perfectly wrapped, and tasted excellent. All enjoyed them, including our 10-year-old. Certainly a splurge item, but well worth it for special occasions.

img 5/5.0 23, May 2024

Excellent Customer Recovery

Ordered two Porterhouse steaks as presents, but one was held up because of a snowstorm. The customer service replied quickly and substituted it, even throwing in free bacon. Made me so impressed with how they managed it. Recipients were extremely delighted.

img 5/5.0 20, May 2024

Memorable Meal with Brothers

Had a wonderful dinner with my brothers from the steak bundle. The meat was good and tender, and it really brought all of us together. Shipping was quick, and everything came in excellent condition. Definitely made our evening special.

img 5/5.0 17, May 2024

The Best Steak Delivery Experience

Having sampled a few other online meat services, I can say with confidence that Mr. Steak is the best all-around experience. The steaks are great ? rich, thick, and obviously top-notch. Their packaging is also excellent at keeping everything fresh and in order, with individual seals for straightforward freezing. I particularly appreciate how even the cuts are ? it makes grilling more predictable and less stressful. Having their infrared grill was also a game-changer. It warms up quickly, sears just right, and cleans up easily. Even weeknight meals have begun to feel like something special. You can tell they've given a lot of thought to the customer experience, from the quality of the meat to the simplicity of their grilling instructions. And their customer service is responsive and helpful, which makes you feel more confident in using their service. For anyone serious about meat, this is the sort of quality and consistency you dream of but never quite find.

img 5/5.0 14, May 2024

Perfect for the Home Grill Master

Mr. Steak is an excellent choice for anyone who enjoys grilling at home. Their steaks are a cut above ? thick, fresh, and full of marbling that makes for juicy, flavorful results. I?ve tried their ribeye and NY strip, and both exceeded expectations. The infrared grill they offer is powerful and easy to use, delivering that steakhouse-style finish without needing special skills. Even my initial try turned out great due to their provided tips. The packaging is also excellent ? everything comes cold, vacuum-sealed, and simple to store. My freezer is now full of Mr. Steak cuts for convenient weeknight dinners or when friends come over. Their service is personalized and reliable, something that doesn't happen much anymore. Each step ? from ordering to grilling ? has been easy and rewarding. It's an affordable way of achieving high-grade results at home. Mr. Steak genuinely comprehends the craving of steak aficionados.

img 5/5.0 11, May 2024

Reliable Quality and Great Results

Having placed a few orders with Mr. Steak, I can say they are among the most dependable sources of high-quality meat. Quality is always maintained ? thick cut, fresh packaging, and transparent labeling make storage and preparation a breeze. Their grill is now our standard for preparing steaks, and it never fails to deliver. I've had their NY strip, ribeye, and filet mignon, and all have been outstanding. The sear holds up flavor wonderfully, and the meat remains tender without much work. My favorite is how simple it's made dining. Add some sides and a steak of theirs, and you have a perfect, tasty meal with minimal ado. Even during hectic weeks, we can get one out of the freezer and still have the quality of meal you get from a restaurant to eat at home. Mr. Steak prides themselves on their service, and it shows. If you're looking for reliable, tasty steak, this is the place.

img 5/5.0 08, May 2024

Flavorful, Tender, and Reliable

Every steak we?ve ordered from Mr. Steak has been packed with flavor and cooked up perfectly. The meat is consistently high quality ? thick cuts with even marbling and excellent freshness. Cooking with their grill takes things to another level, giving that steakhouse-style sear that most home grills can?t achieve. We?ve tried several options, and even the sirloin has been surprisingly tender. The ribeyes and filets are our first picks, however ? both of which have cooked perfectly and stayed juicy every time we've used them. Delivery is always prompt and carefully packaged, so everything stays cold and sorted. We now have some in the freezer for impromptu meals. It's difficult to return to store-bought steaks once you've experienced this. Mr. Steak delivers the whole deal: incredible meat, equipment to cook it well, and superb customer service to go along with it. It's quite probably one of our favorite food discoveries of the year.

img 5/5.0 05, May 2024

Excellent for Steak Enthusiasts

Anyone who enjoys a good steak will love Mr. Steak's products. The product is obviously handpicked ? you don't receive just meat, you receive meat selected for taste, marbling, and texture. It's clear from the packaging to the plate that attention is given to the selection. Preparation of the steaks was easy, particularly with the infrared grill that warms up fast and heats evenly. I used the provided instructions and was amazed at how well the steaks came out. The NY strip was perfect in bite, and the filet was incredibly fork-tender. I'm so glad I can now get restaurant-quality taste without having to go out of the house. The customer support has been phenomenal, always on hand to respond to questions. It's not often that you find this level of quality coupled with convenience. For steak lovers or just someone looking for a better dinner at home, Mr. Steak is an excellent option.

img 5/5.0 02, May 2024

One of the Best Grilling Experiences

Since the first order, Mr. Steak has been one of the greatest grilling experiences I've ever had at home. The steaks are thick, marbled, and come in perfect shape ? fresh, never frozen, and packaged for convenient storage. I've used both the ribeye and NY strip with their infrared grill, and every time the sear was perfect. The heat distribution of the grill makes a big difference ? you don't have to mess around with flipping or concern yourself with hot spots. The meat itself is great. It tastes rich, full, and only requires a little seasoning to be fantastic. I also enjoyed the grilling tips provided with the box, which inspired me to cook better even though I am a beginner. Shipping is always quick, and all of the boxes have come in pristine condition. Mr. Steak has produced a consistent, pleasurable service that delivers steakhouse outcomes right in your own backyard. Couldn't be better.

img 5/5.0 29, Apr 2024

Ideal for Hosting or Everyday Meals

Whether one is entertaining guests to dinner or merely preparing a treat for the family, Mr. Steak does not disappoint. Their product is consistently of superior quality. The meat is top of the line ? tender, juicy, and full of flavor. I have just grilled some steaks recently for a family reunion and the entire group was blown away with the taste and appearance. The steaks were well-cut and cooked uniformly with their infrared grill, which has a fast heat and seals in flavor. I particularly enjoyed the filet mignon and sirloin ? both full of natural taste that didn't require excessive seasoning. The steaks were shipped safely in cold cases and were already ready to grill on the same night. Having pre-cut, sealed portions made it simple to prep and store. Even after being frozen, they grill up great. This service has eliminated the guesswork out of getting good meat. It's reassuring to know that you can rely on Mr. Steak for quality every time, whether it's a weeknight or special occasion.

img 5/5.0 26, Apr 2024

Restaurant-Level Quality at Home

Mr. Steak delivers what they promise ? restaurant-level quality at home. The steaks arrive fresh, generously thick, and visibly top-tier right out of the box. Even the flesh tone and the texture of the meat indicate it's a better cut. I cooked with their infrared grill, which warms up fast and forms a killer sear that traps the juices nicely. Homemade cooking was no fun, let alone when aiming for steakhouse success. With this, now it's simplicity. The ribeye was the best we'd had so far ? rich, tender, and nicely cooked through. Having everything delivered to the door with quality consistently high is really convenient. I've placed repeat orders and each time the experience has been superb. You don't need to be a master to achieve wonderful results. Their step-by-step instructions remove the guesswork from grilling, and the customer service is supportive. Mr. Steak has absolutely revolutionized steak night eating.

img 5/5.0 23, Apr 2024

Worth Every Penny

Initially, I was reluctant to buy steaks online, but Mr. Steak proved me wrong. The quality is self-explanatory. The steaks came cold, nicely vacuum-sealed, and ready to be grilled. What really struck me was the consistency in thickness ? it was so much easier to cook. I grilled on their infrared grill and was astonished at how quickly it heated up to the correct temp. Every steak formed that perfect crust on the outside while remaining juicy on the inside. The ribeye possessed gorgeous marbling, and the NY strip possessed that rich, deep beefy flavor. Every bite was superb. The packaging also made it simple to store or freeze for later, which adds value in my opinion. Their customer service is responsive, and the entire process feels premium without being intimidating. Whether you?re cooking for one or entertaining a group, this is a reliable option. Mr. Steak has absolutely earned a permanent spot in our kitchen.

img 5/5.0 20, Apr 2024

Makes You Look Like a Pro

Mr. Steak assisted me in really taking my grill game to the next level. Prior to this, I had a hard time achieving consistent results, particularly with thicker cuts. Their steaks are perfectly cut and come in perfect condition, vacuum-sealed and ready to go. You can tell they're better than what you can get in the store. The grill sears consistently, locking in flavor without overcooking. My favorite was the filet mignon ? butter soft and bursting with flavor. I've grilled for family and friends, and they all think I must have had professional training. It's that good. Cleanup is easy, and the packaging makes it a cinch to store anything you don't immediately use. I also liked the grilling tips ? it's a big help for someone who wants top performance without guesswork. The whole experience from Mr. Steak is hassle-free, pleasant, and impressive. It's a company that obviously cares about the little things and gets the job done.

img 5/5.0 17, Apr 2024

Seamless from Ordering to Cooking

Mr. Steak offers a smooth and satisfying experience from start to finish. Ordering was simple, and the delivery was right on time with everything packed securely. The steaks themselves were outstanding ? thick, juicy, and well-marbled. Grilling was where they really excelled. The infrared system gave that steakhouse-quality sear, and even the lower-priced cuts were great. I used the directions that came with the box, which made the entire process foolproof. My family now orders these steaks more than we used to from local butcher shops. And we love how convenient it is ? no more running to the grocery store at the last minute or wondering if we're getting good. The packaging is considerate, the flavors are deep, and the tenderness is consistent every time. We've already ordered again and are looking forward to trying some of the other cuts. Mr. Steak has brought real joy to our cooking routine.

img 5/5.0 14, Apr 2024

Truly Elevated Our Weekend Dinners

We wanted to elevate our Saturday night dinners and Mr. Steak came through in every sense. The flavor and tenderness difference was apparent with the first bite. The NY strip had a deep richness, and the ribeye had that perfect combination of fat and lean meat. Packaging kept it fresh, and we appreciated we could freeze what we didn't consume immediately. Their grill guide was super helpful ? even a newbie like me was able to achieve an incredible sear using their infrared grill. The meat seared nicely and evenly, and cleanup was not terrible at all. The thing that makes Mr. Steak stand out to me is the consistency ? each box is as good as the previous one. You can see they're choosy about their product. It?s turned cooking into a fun event for our household, and we?ve even impressed friends with the results. Really great experience all around and one we?ll keep coming back to.

img 5/5.0 11, Apr 2024

Consistently Impressive Cuts

Mr. Steak has become my trusted source for premium cuts. I?ve placed multiple orders, and each time the quality has been spot on. Their ribeyes are some of the best I?ve had outside of a restaurant ? thick, juicy, and richly marbled. Cooking them with their grill creates a consistent sear without overcooking. The result is always juicy and flavorful, even with minimal seasoning. I adore the ease they introduce to cooking. Everything comes pre-measured, individually wrapped, and marked, so I know precisely what I'm dealing with. There's an evident focus on detail in the way they treat the product, from procurement to shipping. Their customer service also gets a mention ? prompt responses and useful advice reassured me right from the beginning. Mr. Steak is not merely a meat delivery service, it's an experience for anyone who enjoys good food and good cooking. Extremely satisfied.

img 5/5.0 08, Apr 2024

A Grilling Game-Changer

Prior to finding Mr. Steak, grilling used to be a hit-or-miss affair even with decent cuts. This service altered that totally. On the initial delivery, I realized that this was not the same thing ? the steaks were sent in temperature-insulated packages, vacuum-packed, and nicely marked. The marbling on the ribeye looked beautiful, and the filet had a nice deep color. Grilling them was a joy, especially using their infrared grill, which sears the exterior beautifully and leaves the inside perfectly tender. The flavor was on par with high-end steakhouses, and my guests couldn?t believe it came from a home grill. I?ve now made several orders and the quality has been reliably consistent. Their website is easy to navigate, and delivery times have been accurate every time. And they provide explicit grilling directions that really remove the guesswork. Weeknight dinners are now something to anticipate thanks to Mr. Steak. It's an experience well worth every cent.

img 5/5.0 05, Apr 2024

Great Value and Superior Taste

After experimenting with a few different steak delivery options, I can honestly say that Mr. Steak provides the best quality and value. Their beef always arrives fresh and well-trimmed, with good-sized cuts that don't dry up too much on the grill. The filet mignon and New York strip were my standouts ? buttery, soft, and richly flavored. Even lightly seasoned, the natural beef flavor broke through nicely. The infrared grill brings another dimension to the experience with an even crust and retaining juices. It cooks quickly and simplifies cooking. What I liked most was how well everything was labeled and packaged. It simplifies portioning and storage. Their customer support was also helpful and responsive, which says a lot. Mr. Steak is a reliable standby for family evening meals and backyard barbecues. If you desire quality without the inconvenience, look no further.

img 5/5.0 02, Apr 2024

High-End Results at Home

Mr. Steak made home-cooked meals luxurious once more. Every steak was obviously chosen with care ? from the even marbling to the thickness and overall freshness. Grilling was a snap with their infrared system, which heated up hotter than my regular grill and helped seal in moisture. I cooked a couple of ribeyes for a special evening meal and both were huge successes. What stood out to me was the consistent texture throughout the cuts ? no stringy bits or uneven cooking. It felt like the kind of steak you?d pay top dollar for in a restaurant, only now it?s a regular experience at home. Their delivery was prompt and professional, with packaging that kept everything cold and organized. No more running to three stores to find decent steaks. Mr. Steak has all bases covered, from good quality meat to friendly guides. Can't wait until my next box. Good old five-star service.

img 5/5.0 30, Mar 2024

Excellent Steaks and Service

Mr. Steak exceeded all expectations. The cuts were wrapped nicely, came chilled, and the quality was evident as soon as I opened the package. The steaks grilled up beautifully ? juicy on the inside with a golden-brown crust reminiscent of a fancy steakhouse. The grill did wonders to bring out that ideal sear, and even the sirloin, which is tough to get right, turned out very tender. I loved how easy it was to work with ? no guessing, just excellent outcomes. The order instructions were extremely helpful, and I enjoy that the packaging is freezer-friendly for future use. It's been pleasant being able to depend on a company that always sends fresh, high-grade steaks without fail. The ease, paired with superb flavor and texture, makes Mr. Steak a sure bet for any meat aficionado. This is my new standby for grilling, entertaining, or simply treating myself to something nicer than grocery-store cuts.

img 5/5.0 27, Mar 2024

Steak Night Just Got Better

Mr. Steak totally revolutionized doing steak night at home. Their meat is very fresh and full of flavor ? the ribeye, in particular, had fantastic marbling and texture. It came well-packed with simple-to-follow handling instructions, and all was vacuum-sealed for freshness. The infrared grill they provide is a great accompaniment. It cooks evenly and produces steaks with a professional sear without drying them out. My household saw the difference immediately ? juicy, tender, and flavorful with just a dash of salt and pepper. Cleanup was rapid, and leftovers were equally good the second day. I also enjoyed the speedy delivery and quality customer support throughout the order process. Both quality product and quality support don't come often, but Mr. Steak does both to a tee. We now regularly use this service and even have a few cuts stored in the freezer for spur-of-the-moment steak nights. Worth. Every. Penny.

img 5/5.0 24, Mar 2024

A Great Find for Steak Lovers

Found Mr. Steak through a friend and have been extremely satisfied with it since. The quality of the meat is significantly higher than what I usually purchase, and the grill is consistent in its performance. The ribeyes were thick, juicy, and perfectly cooked. I didn't need to mess around with marinades or fussy rubs ? the steaks truly speak for themselves. The fact that they were delivered directly to my doorstep, carefully packed and ready to use, makes a significant difference. The infrared grill was simple to put together and used the cooking time wisely and with great enjoyment. The steaks were cooked to a crispy exterior and juicy interior. Even leftover steaks tasted excellent the next day. Mr. Steak has simplified enjoying good meals without the restaurant costs. It's a wonderful choice if you desire reliable service and taste without compromising time or effort. I'll surely be ordering again.

img 5/5.0 21, Mar 2024

Delivers on Taste and Experience

My favorite part about Mr. Steak is the care they put into the whole experience. From packaging to last bite, there's consideration in every process. My order arrived on time, still chilled, and with each cut boldly labeled. I tasted the ribeye and filet first ? both were stunningly marbled and delicious once grilled. Their grill cooked evenly and imparted restaurant-quality crust on each steak. I followed their suggested cooking method, which made it easy and risk-free. My wife and I loved every morsel, and she said it was better than some steakhouse dinners we've had. It was nice to have such confidence in the product throughout the entire process. It's not convenience alone, it's the ability to obtain a top-tier result with the least amount of effort. Mr. Steak has definitely gained a place on our rotation of regular meals. I look forward to experimenting with some of their other boxes in the future.

img 5/5.0 18, Mar 2024

An Upgrade to Home Meals

Steak night previously involved a visit to the butcher and a roll of the dice. No more. Their meat always comes fresh, cold, and in great shape. Freezing is easy with the vacuum-sealed packaging, and the cuts are always even and top quality. I grilled a few ribeyes and was blown away by the flavor. The marbling created a rich, buttery texture that didn?t need anything more than salt and pepper. Even the sirloin was more tender than what I?m used to. Their infrared grill made it easy to get a good sear, and the temperature control was better than my old gas grill. Cleanup was simple too. This configuration puts me on par with a pro in my own back yard. Mr. Steak gives me everything I need to make dinner a special occasion experience ? and now we're dining at home better than we ever did going out.

img 5/5.0 15, Mar 2024

Makes Home Grilling Feel Gourmet

Entering the world of grilling has been a enjoyable pastime, and Mr. Steak has made it take on a new level. The meat they use is always top-notch. My initial order consisted of ribeyes, sirloins, and a filet, and all were fresh, thick, and full of marbling. The difference in flavor and tenderness over store-bought meat was apparent. I accompanied my order with their infrared grill, which sears wonderfully and heats quickly. Even as a novice, I was able to get a perfect medium-rare with little effort. The steaks cooked uniformly and retained their juices. Every bite was savory without the necessity of heavy seasoning. I like how easy it is to store the cuts due to vacuum sealing and clear labeling. This service is convenient but does not compromise the gourmet experience. Grilling is now something I anticipate, and Mr. Steak has a lot to do with it.

img 5/5.0 12, Mar 2024

Better Than Most Steakhouses

One order in, and I was addicted. Mr. Steak brought what tasted like a premium steakhouse experience right to my doorstep. The steaks were sealed separately and came in pristine condition. I grilled them on the infrared equipment, which made a big difference in the way the meat cooked. The outside had a deep, golden sear and the inside was still tender and juicy. Even my most finicky family member said it was one of the best steaks they'd ever had ? even better than a few restaurants we've eaten at. The entire ordering process was efficient, and the site was simple to use. Everything was packaged nicely and was recyclable, which was a nice touch. I've since experimented with several different cuts and have been consistently impressed along the way. Mr. Steak provides both top-notch products and a hassle-free experience, which is hard to come by with online food delivery. It's now my go-to means of having quality steaks at home.

img 5/5.0 09, Mar 2024

Perfect for Entertaining Guests

Ordered a Mr. Steak box for a dinner party on a weekend and was really impressed with the whole process. The steaks came as scheduled, nicely chilled and well packed. Each piece appeared professionally cut, with healthy marbling and clean trims. I seasoned a mix of them all ? ribeyes, strips, and filets ? and each of my guests raved about the taste and texture. The infrared grill performed just as well, warming quickly and cooking consistently. The best part was how effortless entertaining became. No hassle about running to a butcher, no questioning the quality of the meat, and the outcome said it all. It was like having a high-end steakhouse dinner at home. Cleanup was simple, and we even had some leftovers that were delicious the next day. This has become my standard for special occasions and whenever I want to impress guests without the restaurant bill.

img 5/5.0 06, Mar 2024

Great Quality and Hassle-Free

Steak nights have become a regular thing at home thanks to Mr. Steak. The quality of the meat is better than anything I?ve found at local markets. Each cut was sealed, labeled, and arrived fresh. The New York strip and ribeye were incredibly juicy, and the flavor really stood out, even with minimal seasoning. Their grill makes the process faster and more enjoyable ? perfect sear every time, no flare-ups or guesswork. I particularly liked the user-friendly experience: speedy delivery, concise grilling directions, and easy-to-store packaging. Even customer service was kind when I inquired about delivery times. Overall, everything in the experience was considered and streamlined. Whether cooking for yourself or making a meal for guests, the convenience and taste are totally worth it. This service has made my cooking process easier and set a new standard for what I look for in meat delivery.

img 5/5.0 03, Mar 2024

Everything You?d Want in a Steak Box

Mr. Steak went above and beyond all expectations. The second I opened the box, everything was neatly laid out and clearly marked. The quality of the meat was immediately apparent ? thick slices, deep color, and perfectly trimmed. I grilled the filet mignon and ribeye, both were full of flavor and extremely tender. Instructions for cooking were clear and useful, even for a person who is not completely sure of themselves on the grill. The infrared grill definitely paid off though ? it's easy to heat up and cook evenly. The steaks acquired an amazing sear without becoming dry. The whole experience, from ordering to being served, was seamless and pleasant. There?s something special about having restaurant-level food right at home. It?s a game-changer for dinner nights and entertaining guests. I?ve since reordered and received the same level of quality and care. Mr. Steak has become a reliable source of great meals and consistent service. Excellent value all around.

img 5/5.0 29, Feb 2024

Best Steak I?ve Cooked at Home

Home cooking has always been a pleasure, but Mr. Steak raised the bar. The ribeye I had was stunningly marbled and a rich red color, obviously top-quality meat. It grilled perfectly on their infrared grill ? juicy on the inside, with a great crust. What really impressed me was the uniform quality from cut to cut. The filet was equally tender and full of flavor. Delivery was smooth, and the packaging maintained all items at the perfect temperature. I also liked the vacuum-sealed portions that facilitated easy storage. It's convenient without compromising quality, which is not so common in food delivery. I have tried other meat subscriptions, but this has been most rewarding in terms of both taste and service. For anyone who loves a good steak at home without the restaurant bill, this is a great option. Will be ordering again for sure ? it's a staple in my kitchen now.

img 5/5.0 26, Feb 2024

Meat Lovers? Dream Come True

As someone who takes grilling seriously, I?ve tried a lot of different meat delivery services ? but Mr. Steak stands out. The quality of the meat is exceptional. The steaks are thick, well-trimmed, and marbled perfectly for flavor. What stands out to me is the focus on the way the product is packaged and shipped. My shipment came cold, well-packaged, and precisely as described. I grilled the ribeyes and was impressed at how they tasted. It was reminiscent of high-end steakhouses. Even better, the infrared grill they sell truly brings out the cooking experience. It warms up quickly and distributes heat evenly for a perfect crust. The service has been excellent, and I've never had a late or wrong order. This isn't limited to special occasions, though ? it's perfect for steak nights on a regular basis, especially when you want that added quality without going out. Excellent value for serious grillers.

img 5/5.0 23, Feb 2024

Reliable Service, Excellent Quality

I have ordered from Mr. Steak several times now, and all the experiences have been thoroughly good. The steaks come out fresh, chilled, and packed very safely. I like having options to choose from, from the top-notch ribeyes up to the more convenient sirloins. Every cut was fat-marbled beautifully and convenient to cook. Meat quality shines greatly when you compare them with store offerings. Grilling them on the Mr. Steak infrared grill releases even more flavor ? the sear you end up with is indomitable. Their customer service is also quick to respond; I had a minor tracking problem once, and they sorted it out promptly. It shows they care about both product and service. I've used the steaks for date nights, BBQ nights, and meal prep. They hold up well in the freezer, which makes stocking up easy. For anyone who enjoys a good steak and values consistency, Mr. Steak delivers.

img 5/5.0 20, Feb 2024

Weekend Dinner Was a Hit

Our weekend dinner plans turned into a memorable evening thanks to Mr. Steak. We ordered a steak box with a combination of ribeyes, sirloins, and filets, and all of them were beyond expectations. The packaging was great at keeping everything cold and in order. It was simple to unpack and prep. The grilling tips included were very helpful, particularly for someone like me who tends to wing it. The ribeye had incredible marbling and a strong flavor, and the filet was tender and melt-in-your-mouth. Everyone at the table was amazed and wanted to know where we purchased them. It was like eating at a fine steakhouse but without the throng or price tag. Even cleanup was kept to a minimum, which added to the enjoyment of the experience. Mr. Steak has made it simple for us to make special dinners at home. This won't be an isolated order ? I'm already thinking about what to order next. Certainly a good find.

img 5/5.0 17, Feb 2024

Outstanding Meat and Easy Setup

Since I've now had the experience of Mr. Steak's grill and meat delivery, I can say it's well worth the money. The grill arrangement was simple, and the infrared technology does a great job of searing steaks perfectly. Even as a complete grill novice, I was able to get that restaurant-quality finish. The steaks were sealed vacuum-style and color-coded, and it was effortless to recognize what cut of beef each one represented. My picks were the filet mignon and the ribeye ? luxurious, meaty, and savory without a ton of complicated seasonings. Every package came through promptly, with the packaging methods keeping everything well-chilled and secure. That is exactly how much service it takes to accomplish convenience without forgoing quality. I no longer need to make special trips to the butcher shop or worry about whether what I?m getting is fresh. Whether you?re hosting guests or just want to treat yourself, Mr. Steak makes it incredibly easy to enjoy a high-end meal at home.

img 5/5.0 14, Feb 2024

Great Option for Special Dinners

Ordered Mr. Steak for a birthday celebration at home, and it was a huge success. The meat came cold and fresh, stored safely in vacuum-sealed packets with dry ice. There was a thickness of steak to each cut and they appeared to be freshly pulled from a gourmet butcher. We grilled the filet mignon as well as the New York strip, and both turned out great. The filet was tender with a subtle, rich flavor, and the strip possessed that traditional beefy chomp. What impressed me most was the consistency of quality ? each steak performed on flavor and texture. This is not just a convenient service; it's a truly superior choice to purchasing meat at a neighborhood supermarket. Each aspect of the experience felt upgraded, from the unboxing to the actual meal. If you want to impress dinner party guests or just have a fancy meal at home, Mr. Steak is a worthwhile and trustworthy option.

img 5/5.0 11, Feb 2024

Truly Elevated My Grilling Game

Decided to try Mr. Steak after reading reviews and was pleasantly surprised by how much it upgraded my at-home cooking. The grill arrived first and was easy to assemble. It heats quickly and evenly, perfect for searing thick cuts. I ordered a mixed box of steaks to accompany it, and all the cuts were excellent. The ribeye boasted beautiful marbling and a creamy texture when cooked. Even the sirloin, which had a tendency to be dry sometimes, was juicy and full of flavor. I liked how each item was properly labeled, vacuum-sealed, and portioned perfectly. It arrived on time, and nothing got warm while in transit. There is a real attention to detail in the products and the service. It is much better value than eating out at a steakhouse, and more fun too. Grilling has become something I really look forward to, all thanks to the tools and steaks from Mr. Steak.

img 5/5.0 08, Feb 2024

Steakhouse Flavor in My Backyard

Once I have tried Mr. Steak, I no longer need to go to a steakhouse. The cuts are top-notch, with excellent marbling and a vivid, deep red color that shouts premium. Packaging was solid and kept the steaks cool all the way to my doorstep. I cooked the ribeyes using their infrared grill, and the sear was as good as what I experience in pricey restaurants. The meat remained juicy on the inside, with that wonderful char on the outside. Instructions were easy and straightforward, so the entire process was simple even for someone like me who is not a grilling master. The steaks themselves were the true star ? tender, flavorful, and filling. You could tell they were prepared with care. It made for a great family dinner. Definitely something I?ll keep in mind for special occasions or even just a well-deserved treat at home.

img 5/5.0 05, Feb 2024

Simple and Satisfying

No fancy directions, no tricks ? only fine steak. The quality says it all. You don't have to do much more than salt, pepper, and good timing. Packing was tidy, and nothing showed up thawed or broken. This is the way high-end food delivery is supposed to make you feel: straightforward, dependable, and satisfying.

img 5/5.0 02, Feb 2024

Worth the Splurge

Yes, it's pricier than the average?albeit with a noticeable difference. The quality of texture, flavor, and cut accuracy makes it worth every penny, particularly if you happen to value cooking excellent meals. I've had only positive experiences and will continue to make repeat purchases for special meals and weekend dinners. Clearly a cut above the supermarket offerings.

img 5/5.0 30, Jan 2024

A New Favorite

Found Mr. Steak from a friend and have ordered two times since. All of it has come cold, well packaged, and in great shape. The meat is excellent quality, and customer service is quick to respond. Have tried other delivery companies, but this one excels at attention to detail and consistent results.

img 5/5.0 27, Jan 2024

Ideal for Occasional Treats

Don't buy meat online frequently, but Mr. Steak simplified things. The box was sturdy, steaks appeared to be top quality, and instructions for cooking were straightforward. Good for indulging yourself without having to go to a steakhouse. A bit expensive for every week, but wonderful when you wish to have a quality meal at home.

img 5/5.0 24, Jan 2024

Grilling Made Simple

Utilized to second-guess timing and temps on steak, but the guides by Mr. Steak made a huge difference. The meats themselves are such high quality that it does not take a whole lot of work to get optimum results. On cast iron grill and open flames, both ended up being fabulous. Convenient having a one-source solution for decent meats.

img 5/5.0 21, Jan 2024

Thoughtful Presentation

Every aspect of the order felt thought through ? from the vacuum-sealed beef to dry ice shipping and packaged instructions. The steaks were beautifully colored and just the right thickness. Upon cooking, the flavor came through exactly as one would see. A bit pricier, perhaps, but the attention to detail is evident in each step. A dependable service.

img 5/5.0 18, Jan 2024

Steak Box Was Well-Curated

Ordered one of their mixed boxes and was pleased with the assortment. Received a good variety of cuts, all of which cooked well. It's obvious someone thoughtfully put the mix together. Enjoyed sampling different kinds of steak without having to invest in one large pack. A great way to try new favorites.

img 5/5.0 15, Jan 2024

Infrared Grill Was a Game-Changer

Not sure about the infrared grill initially, but it has completely revolutionized the way I prepare steaks. Heats quickly and sears perfectly. The meat remains juicy on the inside with a crunchy outside crust. Paired with Mr. Steak's cuts, it produces consistent results every time. Excellent investment for anyone serious about grilling.

img 5/5.0 12, Jan 2024

Excellent for Small Gatherings

Had a box for a small gathering and everyone loved it. The assortment of cuts was easy to satisfy different tastes. Grilled all with very little seasoning, and the flavor stood strong. Even asked the guests where I procured them. Will be using this again for parties or just casual night dinners.

img 5/5.0 09, Jan 2024

Easy Ordering and Fast Shipping

Ordering process was fast and easy. Received my confirmation email immediately, and the box within the delivery timeframe. Steaks were shipped properly with dry ice and remained frozen. All of it appeared to be professional and clean. Grilled the sirloin on the same night, and it tasted great. Excellent experience all the way through.

img 5/5.0 06, Jan 2024

Steakhouse Quality at Home

Cooked the steaks alongside some purchased at a local butcher, and Mr. Steak won. Better texture, more intense flavor, and cooked more consistently. The difference was unmistakable. Tossed on a salad and a bottle of wine, and it was like dining out. This is a nice alternative for people who like nice meals at home.

img 5/5.0 03, Jan 2024

Big Upgrade from Local Stores

Used to purchase steaks from the grocery store, but Mr. Steak is a different world. Improved marbling, improved flavor, and improved packaging. It tastes and smells fresher and more painstakingly sourced. You pay for what you get here. Simple to prepare and includes instructions for optimal outcome. Amazed with what I ordered.

img 5/5.0 31, Dec 2023

Great for Meal Prep

Purchased a variety pack and utilized the steaks over several meals throughout the week. Seared one, cut up another for salads, and put a few aside in the freezer. All tasted excellent and stayed fresh. Nice to have consistent meat on the shelf without having to make an extra trip. Excellent quality for convenience.

img 5/5.0 28, Dec 2023

Consistently High Quality

This was my third purchase, and the quality hasn't declined. Each cut I've received has been fresh, delicious, and simple to prepare. The vacuum sealing keeps everything neat and secure. Truly makes a difference knowing you can rely on what you receive. Not the most affordable, but for the experience and outcome, it's worth it.

img 5/5.0 25, Dec 2023

Weekend Meal Hit

Tested out the Mr. Steak box for a family supper. Everyone made comments about how tender and how good the meat tasted. Grilled everything and it was restaurant-quality. Even the sides that we prepared felt special because the steaks tasted so good. Delivery arrived precisely on time. A wonderful way to make a weekend feel extra special.

img 5/5.0 22, Dec 2023

Solid Customer Service

Had a small problem with the address on my order, and customer support got it fixed in no time. Greatly appreciated the quick responses. The steaks were fantastic ? delicious, well-packaged, and arrived chilled. You can tell attention is paid to every detail throughout the process. A big difference from purchasing from a supermarket.".

img 5/5.0 19, Dec 2023

Premium Experience at Home

The packaging, the meat quality, and the delivery all reflect a higher-end experience. Cooked the NY strips and was impressed with the flavor and tenderness. Didn?t need heavy seasoning ? just salt and pepper did the job. It?s not something I?d do every week, but perfect for an occasional treat or gathering. Solid experience overall.

img 5/5.0 16, Dec 2023

Great Gift Option

Ordered a box for my brother's birthday, and he loved it. Arrived on time, well-packaged, and the cuts were thick and premium-looking. He grilled them that weekend and said they were the best steaks he'd had at home. It's a good gift for someone who likes to cook or grill. Will use again for holidays.

img 5/5.0 13, Dec 2023

Reliable and Flavorful

This was my second order, and it equaled the quality of the first. Meat was fresh, properly cut, and well-marbled. Instructions on cooking provided were useful. Like that the experience is uniform each time. Delivery has been quick and courteous. Makes hosting or special meals a lot easier and less stressful.

img 5/5.0 10, Dec 2023

Impressive Grill Performance

Purchased one of their infrared grills and complemented it with a steak box. The grill warms up fast and sears beautifully. The meat is robust in quality, but the grill truly brings it out. Installation took some time, but once installed, it was well worth it. Experienced the full steakhouse flavor at home. Extremely useful for steak enthusiasts.

img 5/5.0 07, Dec 2023

Steak Night Upgrade

Attempted Mr. Steak to elevate our weekly steak nights, and it did not disappoint. The filets were tender, juicy, and flavorful. They seared perfectly on a cast iron skillet and remained moist on the inside. Packaging was cold and organized. Customer service was courteous when I called with a question. It's a great way to take home dinners to the next level.

img 5/5.0 04, Dec 2023

Better Than Expected

Honestly didn't have high hopes, but was surprised. The ribeyes were juicy and had great marbling. Cooked one on a cast iron skillet and the other on the grill ? both came out wonderful. The meat was fresh-tasting and didn't require much seasoning. Packaging was tidy and everything was delivered on time. Good value.

img 5/5.0 01, Dec 2023

Quality and Convenience Combined

The most impressive thing was how straightforward it was. No going to the butcher, and the quality was on or better than equal. The steaks heated up evenly and possessed excellent texture and flavor. The package was secure, and the delivery was timely. It's a great choice if you'd like something extra special without the inconvenience of shopping around.

img 5/5.0 28, Nov 2023

Great First Experience

Was doubtful about buying steak online, but Mr. Steak made it a breeze. Site is easy to read and provides good information, and ordering function was seamless. Steaks were well-wrapped and still frozen. Grilled them up and they were both juicy and tasting great. Way better than steaks at the local store. Will be buying again soon for another weekend barbeque.

img 5/5.0 25, Nov 2023

Excellent Cuts Delivered Fresh

Ordered my first time from Mr. Steak and was truly impressed. The packaging was heavy-duty and maintained everything at the proper temperature. The steaks were thick, fresh, and well-marbled. Cooked them medium-rare, and the taste was rich and rewarding. You can tell these aren't your run-of-the-mill supermarket cuts. Delivery was prompt, and everything arrived exactly as promised.

img 2/5.0 22, Nov 2023

Too Much Fat on the Ribeye

Ribeye was all fat and little meat. Some fat is to be expected, but this was too much. Did not receive the value I had anticipated. Won't likely be attempting again.

img 2/5.0 19, Nov 2023

Lacked Seasoning Suggestions

No seasoning suggestions or prep advice offered. First-time buyers could have used that. Seemed like a lost chance to lead the experience.

img 2/5.0 16, Nov 2023

Texture Was Tougher Than Expected

Used all cooking instructions but the meat remained tough and chewy. Doesn't live up to the premium branding they promote.

img 2/5.0 13, Nov 2023

Steaks Arrived Late

Despite rush shipping, my order took two days to arrive after the expected date. The steaks were okay, but the delay was inconvenient for meal planning.

img 1/5.0 10, Nov 2023

Refund Process Was Frustrating

Asked for a partial refund because the delivery was damaged. Had to send multiple emails and still didn't receive a direct answer. Support system seems chaotic.

img 2/5.0 07, Nov 2023

Grill Didn?t Improve Results

Purchased the grill hoping for restaurant-quality sears. What I got was uneven cooking and flare-ups. Not the smooth experience I envisioned.

img 2/5.0 04, Nov 2023

One Cut Was Off-Color

The majority of the meat was good, but there was one ribeye that was an unusual color and had a slight smell. Didn't want to eat it. Reached out to support and never heard back.

img 2/5.0 01, Nov 2023

Overpriced for the Quality

It's presented as a gourmet experience, but it tasted like grocery store steaks in more expensive packaging. Not terrible, but definitely not worth the additional expense.

img 1/5.0 29, Oct 2023

Packaging Didn?t Keep Items Secure

Box arrived partially open with steaks tossed about. Didn't give us confidence, particularly as meat handling is so important. Won't be ordering again.

img 2/5.0 26, Oct 2023

Meat Didn?t Live Up to Promise

Steakhouse-quality beef promise was not met. It cooked well but was not rich and full of flavor. Simply did not perform like hyped.

img 2/5.0 23, Oct 2023

Grill Setup Instructions Confusing

Bought a grill and had issues with the instructions. Diagrams were not understandable, and took much longer than anticipated to put together. Could use improved documentation.

img 1/5.0 20, Oct 2023

Communication Was Lacking

No shipping update, no delivery notification. The lack of customer communication made it a stressful experience. Expected more from an online meat company.

img 2/5.0 17, Oct 2023

Price Doesn?t Reflect Quality

You?re paying for branding, not better beef. The steaks looked impressive but tasted average. Have had better results from local butchers at a fraction of the cost.

img 2/5.0 14, Oct 2023

Steaks Too Lean

The cuts were too lean and devoid of the fat marbling that makes steak flavorful. Perfectly cooked, but still was dry. Was disappointed with the offer.

img 1/5.0 11, Oct 2023

Packaging Leak Made Me Worry

One of the vacuum-sealed bags leaked blood when it came. Didn't feel comfortable cooking it. Didn't anticipate that from a supposed top-shelf provider.

img 2/5.0 08, Oct 2023

Grill Was Underwhelming

Purchased the infrared grill and had trouble regulating temperatures. Did not make any better food than my standard gas grill. Not worth the cost.

img 2/5.0 05, Oct 2023

Taste Didn?t Match Price

Steaks were good but nothing special. If this was a budget choice, perhaps. But for how much it costs, I thought much better both in flavor and texture.

img 2/5.0 02, Oct 2023

Website Is Hard to Navigate

Attempted to make a purchase, but the checkout process was buggy and slow. Not a seamless user experience. Expected a more refined platform for a higher-end product.

img 2/5.0 29, Sep 2023

Overhyped Product

Marketing made me think this was next-level steak. It wasn't. Cooked to a medium-rare and still found it to be bland and chewy. There are better steaks available elsewhere.

img 1/5.0 26, Sep 2023

Delivery Delay Without Notice

Package was two days late with no warning. Meat was still chilled, but the delay spoiled things. Lack of transparency did harm to experience.

img 2/5.0 23, Sep 2023

Smaller Than Expected Portions

Serving portions were less than expected. Although the meat was not bad, it seemed overpriced for what was received. Hoped for better for money.

img 2/5.0 20, Sep 2023

Steak Quality Was Inconsistent

First shipment was decent, but second was not. Unusual texture, strange odor, and hard to chew. Not a brand you can trust to come through every time.

img 1/5.0 17, Sep 2023

Customer Service Didn?t Help

Contacted about a delivery problem and received an auto-message with no call-back. For a company that presents itself as premium, the service came across as extremely low-end.

img 2/5.0 14, Sep 2023

Packaging Was Subpar

Steaks were not tightly packed, and one seal was broken by the time it arrived. Quality control could use a bit of work. Not worth paying premium price.

img 2/5.0 11, Sep 2023

Lackluster Flavor

Steaks came on time but failed to deliver on the promise. Texture was good, but flavor simply wasn't there. Considering the cost, I would have expected a better outcome.

img 2/5.0 08, Sep 2023

Difficult to Justify the Cost

Following several positive reviews, I was hoping for Mr. Steak to provide a really special meat experience. The product failed to live up to the price tag, however. Steaks were fine?above average?just not great. Not worth the premium they're charging, by any means. Portion sizes were smaller than I would have liked, and the cuts weren't nearly marbled enough to provide that rich flavor characteristic of steakhouse-quality beef. Tried different cooking methods, but none elevated the meat to the level I?d hoped for. Even more frustrating was the lack of flexibility when ordering. No way to customize boxes or select specific quantities. It?s a one-size-fits-all approach, which doesn?t work when paying premium prices. Other services I?ve used offered better quality, clearer information, and more responsive customer care. Mr. Steak may suit others, but it failed to produce the exceptional quality that I sought. Not going to spend this type of money here again. The experience did not meet up.

img 1/5.0 05, Sep 2023

Inferior Cuts in a Supposedly Premium Box

Ordered one of Mr. Steak's mixed boxes hoping for a well-chosen assortment of premium cuts. What I got was anything but premium. A number of the steaks were badly trimmed, with a lot of fat and gristle. One filet was unevenly cut, which impacted cooking and presentation. For something marketed as a gourmet assortment, the box seemed to be filled with leftover or inferior cuts. Attempted to salvage it with seasoning and sous vide, but the final products were still subpar. The taste was not special and the texture was off. This was not a one-time meal?it was an entire order that wasn't impressive. Reached out to the company and got a friendly but non-solution response. No solution offered to correct or look into further. If you pay top-shelf dollars, you want to get quality, consistency, and care. Mr. Steak failed on all three counts. Can't recommend from what I've experienced and won't be reordering.

img 2/5.0 02, Sep 2023

Customer Support Needs Improvement

When purchasing a higher-end product, the customer support needs to be active and supportive. That did not happen at Mr. Steak. I simply had a query regarding a shipping problem?nothing time-sensitive?but the answers provided were delayed, copy-paste, and did not completely answer my question. The team seemed too intent on closing out tickets rather than actually resolving issues. While the steaks weren't awful, the whole experience was marred by bad communication. Even their website lacked detail and troubleshooting information, which left me only able to use email support. If a business is going to charge an premium price, it needs to deliver premium service across the board. This was more like a mid-range business with a premium veneer. It's frustrating when simple customer service is disregarded. More competence in that area could have made the product feel more worthy. As things stand, I will not be repeating the purchase.

img 1/5.0 30, Aug 2023

Quality Declined on Repeat Orders

My initial order from Mr. Steak made a good impression?steaks were delivered in good shape, were well-marbled, and cooked well. That encouraged me to order again a few weeks later, and that order was much worse. The steaks were thinner, less marbled, and the packaging was sloppy compared to the previous order. One of the cuts even had a grayish color, and I wondered about its freshness. Attempted to reach customer service but was met with a generic "all products meet our standards" answer, which did not specifically respond to the concerns. The inconstancy between orders makes it difficult to have faith in the brand in the future. There should be some quality control at this price point, but it was a roll of the dice. A business can't earn loyalty on one positive experience if it can't continue that level of quality. I?ve since switched to a different meat delivery provider and haven?t had these issues. Won?t be returning to Mr. Steak.

img 2/5.0 27, Aug 2023

Poor Packaging Diminished Confidence

When ordering meat online, packaging is everything. Unfortunately, my Mr. Steak delivery didn?t inspire confidence. While the steaks were cold, the vacuum seals were loose on a couple of cuts, and the box interior looked hastily packed. Some pieces shifted around during transit and were squished against the cardboard. For a brand promoting steakhouse-level quality, this kind of carelessness undermines the whole promise. The meat itself was cooked fine, but the process up to that point had already raised suspicions. Contacted support, who recognized the problem but provided only a minor discount code rather than a partial refund or exchange. With the premium price point and perishable product, improved packaging and more responsive service are not negotiable. It was a product that seemed over-hyped and under-performing. I anticipated a professional-level presentation and deliberate management?not one that appeared to be hasty and half-baked in terms of planning.

img 1/5.0 24, Aug 2023

Not the Premium Experience Promised

Anticipated a high-end experience from Mr. Steak from their advertising, but the experience didn't live up. The meat was good-looking but not tender or flavorful like high-end cuts. Used proper cooking methods and even experimented with other methods, but nothing could elicit anything worth remembering from the product. It tasted like generic grocery store beef with nicer packaging. For the cost, this was disappointing. To that end, order tracking was ambiguous, and delivery came after the estimated window. There was no notification of delay, and when I contacted them, customer service gave a blanket response with no actual explanation. A premium brand should not only offer great meat but also a refined, trustworthy experience from beginning to end. That wasn't what happened here. Among the lackluster steaks and subpar service, it's difficult to order again. Better more consistent options are available elsewhere.

img 1/5.0 21, Aug 2023

One Good Experience, One Bad

My initial order was decent, and the steaks were great, though smaller than anticipated. The second order, however, was a complete different experience. The shipment was late, the meat was partially thawed when it arrived, and two of the vacuum seals were loose. When I reached out to support, they requested pictures, which I sent, but there was no follow-up. I finally got a coupon code?not even a replacement?what with the amount of money I spent. It's the inconsistency and lack of proactive support that really turned me off. When you?re dealing with perishables, it?s critical for the company to handle mishaps quickly and effectively. A good first impression was ruined by poor follow-through. Consistency and trust are everything with food delivery, and unfortunately, Mr. Steak didn?t deliver on either the second time around. I?ve since gone back to using other services that have proven more dependable and responsive.

img 2/5.0 18, Aug 2023

Limited Cut Selection Online

Wanted to place a bulk order for a variety of premium steak cuts but found the website selection quite limited. Most bundles offer the same few cuts, with little room for customization. Was hoping for options like skirt steak, hanger steak, or even different grades, but everything felt overly curated. For a company attempting to attract steak lovers, there needs to be greater leniency. Also saw that various cuts were unavailable for weeks, making it difficult to plan a special meal. Had to settle for a smaller box that did not contain all I desired. Quality was good, but not great, and the variety overall was not worth ordering again in the future. For a meat delivery service that boasts about its gourmet options, the choices tasted generic and uninspired. Would suggest they expand their offerings to appeal to more adventurous or dedicated home cooks. Until that day, it's a pass from me.

img 1/5.0 15, Aug 2023

Cold Pack Failure on Arrival

Received my order in a box with dry ice that had completely melted. The steaks were no longer cold to the touch and didn?t seem safe to consume. Called the company right away and sent pictures of the situation, but the company was slow to respond and seemed nonchalant. Was informed that someone would contact me with a solution, but it didn't happen until more than a week later. While waiting, I was forced to discard more than $150 worth of meat. Realize that delays in shipping are possible, but for perishables, there must be much more attention and sensitivity when things fail. The entire experience made me hesitant to buy meat online once again. There was no urgency on their part to take responsibility or correct the situation. With the high-end price point, you would want high-end customer service. That did not occur here. Definitely not the kind of service I?d risk repeating, especially for perishable food items.

img 2/5.0 12, Aug 2023

Website Felt Misleading

The manner in which the website displays the products makes everything appear larger, fresher, and more gourmet than what arrives. The steaks appeared good but were much smaller than anticipated, and the cuts were not as thick or generous as indicated. There is also no information regarding weight per steak unless you search for it. It felt deceptive?particularly once you see how much you've spent on what really is just average grocery store quantities. The pictures and words build expectations very high, and the product delivered can't live up to them. It's not inherently bad meat, but it's certainly not what the site makes it out to be. Honesty and true representation are important when selling online, particularly with something that will spoil. Felt a bit tricked by the presentation. For what it?s worth, I?ll be sticking with local sources or other providers that give a clearer idea of what you?re actually buying.

img 1/5.0 09, Aug 2023

Didn?t Meet Expectations for Quality

Ordered with anticipation due to the site's promotion and imagery. What I got fell short in a few different areas. The steaks were irregular in shape and did not resemble the pictures. The marbling was poor, and the steaks were thin for what they promised. Grilling them did not produce the tender, juicy product I was seeking?instead, the texture was heavy and had no flavor. Even with special seasoning and searing, they tasted more like cheap cuts than steakhouse offerings. After contacting customer support for clarification, I wasn't given much more than a standard apology. It's frustrating when the actual product seems light-years from what the company claims. If you're going to charge premium prices, you have to provide a premium experience end-to-end. Unfortunately, this felt more like a marketing-led business than one driven by real quality. Would not buy again based on this experience alone.

img 2/5.0 06, Aug 2023

Inconsistent Product Presentation

One thing that really stood out to me was how differently every order was packaged and presented. Sometimes steaks were vacuum-sealed properly, but sometimes the seals were loose or contained air pockets. One of the orders even had visible freezer burn along the edges of the steaks, which shouldn't ever occur with fresh, stored meat. It concerned me about how much their cold chain management is consistent, really. The steaks themselves were fine, but the uneven packaging and storage labels dented my trust in the product. If you're going to market something as premium, consistency is paramount, and this certainly wasn't that. It led me to wonder if they're expanding their business too far without holding themselves to high standards. Compared to other businesses I've tried, Mr. Steak was more hurried and not as dependable. For the cost and promise, it was not comparable, and I won't be giving them another chance down the road.

img 1/5.0 03, Aug 2023

Issues with Infrared Grill Purchase

Purchased one of their infrared grills upon noticing a package offer with both meat and the machine. Received the grill with some parts missing, such as a drip tray and screws for assembly. Contacted customer service, but the response was very slow. Upon the arrival of the missing parts, they did not belong to the model I ordered, rendering it unusable. The overall construction of the grill felt less expensive than it should have been at the price point. It was also hard to put together, with confusing instructions and no useful video content available on the website. The process was frustrating and made grilling more of a chore than an enjoyable experience. Had to end up using my old gas grill instead. Between the product quality issues and poor customer support, it wasn't a premium experience by any stretch. Would not suggest purchasing hardware from Mr. Steak unless quality control and support are improved.

img 2/5.0 31, Jul 2023

Lack of Clear Cooking Instructions

Though the steaks were delivered cold and in reasonable condition, there was minimal of any real help with cooking them. For a brand focused on providing premium steakhouse quality, one would expect detailed instructions or suggestions to help bring out the best in the meat. Instead, it felt like a generic delivery without much thought put into the experience. Tried following basic online guides, but the end result was hit or miss. A simple recipe card or digital guide could have helped avoid overcooking or undercooking. Presentation is half the deal, and this segment was totally ignored. The meat itself was just okay, but lacking knowledge of proper ways to prepare it, it's difficult to reap the full advantage. I felt like I was on my own to sort that out. For those not so sure in the kitchen, this isn't the best option unless they better support preparation. All in all, a waste of potential.

img 1/5.0 28, Jul 2023

No Follow-Up on a Refund Request

Experienced severe problems with my order?delayed shipment, hot package, and compromised meat condition. I called customer service immediately and was informed someone would call me back. Weeks went by, and I called twice to follow up, but heard nothing beyond a general acknowledgement. It's so infuriating to feel like you're being ignored after spending a lot on what's presented as a premium service. A quick follow-up would have sorted everything out, but the fact that they didn't respond made me feel like they just didn't care. Not only did I end up wasting half of the order, but I also felt like I'd wasted my time and money. Businesses that sell perishable items must have sensitive, effective support staff?particularly when the unexpected occurs. There was no accountability and an attempt to rectify the situation here. My first and last visit with Mr. Steak. Not a company I would ever trust again.

img 2/5.0 25, Jul 2023

Cooking Results Were Inconsistent

Ordered several steaks to get to try on consecutive weeks. All of them acted differently over the grill based on the identical treatment. They were tender here, abnormally chewy elsewhere, or instantly dried out elsewhere. The consistency was truly spoiling the pleasure and left a negative impression upon the quality check. Expected a top-shelf cut to remain consistently great by batch. Otherwise, it would feel like putting one's stomach in luck whenever. Tried both the sirloin and ribeye, and even the marbling was hit or miss. There was no consistency in how they cooked or tasted. For the cost, I was looking for not only good taste but consistent results. That wasn't the case here, and it caused frustration instead of satisfaction. Would have liked to know I could rely on each piece being the same. That inconsistent quality is why I'll be switching to other suppliers that ship more reliably, even if at lower prices.

img 1/5.0 22, Jul 2023

Didn?t Live Up to the Hype

The ad made Mr. Steak look like the end-all be-all for steak enthusiasts, but it just didn't live up to expectation. The packaging was cheap, and the steaks looked mediocre. Cooking didn't improve much?the meat was not buttery and melt-in-your-mouth like you'd want at this price. Even with exact cooking temperatures, the steaks lost their tenderness and became dry. Felt more like supermarket quality rather than a specialty steakhouse experience. It?s disappointing to feel like you?ve paid more for flashy branding rather than actual product quality. Was really hoping to impress guests with a high-end meal, but the results fell flat and led to embarrassment. Tried reaching out to the company for feedback but never got a useful response. For something touted as premium, there is a very big difference between the advertisement and the truth. Will not buy here again and would suggest others to be careful before shelling out their cash here.

img 2/5.0 19, Jul 2023

Not Ideal for Gifting

Purchased a gift box from Mr. Steak for a birthday gift to give to a friend. The gift was a day late when it arrived and looked nothing like it should have. The outside box was creased, and the inside contents had been jostled around so that it gave a disorganized look. This was going to be a high-end gift, yet it lacked that high-quality touch that you get when investing this amount of money. My friend liked the gesture but said the steaks did not look particularly fresh, and one of the vacuum seals leaked. For a business marketing high-end products good enough for gifting, the failure to pay attention to presentation and shipping quality was irritating. Contacted customer support and got only a canned response without any actual solution. There are better curated and more trustworthy gift delivery services available, and I will not be selecting Mr. Steak again for this reason. The experience was less enjoyable than worth it.

img 1/5.0 16, Jul 2023

Flavor Was Underwhelming

Expected a lot from the taste, considering Mr. Steak's high-end reputation. Sadly, the meat fell short of depth and richness associated with prime-grade beef. Grilled and cooked in cast iron, attempting to get the best out of it, but still, the outcome was the same?bland and unmemorable. The marbling was not even, and the steaks failed to sear well, making them pale even when cooked right. For a steakhouse-quality brand, this was a miss. Even less expensive meat I've bought at the local supermarket tasted better and had a higher quality texture. It's hard to spend more money if the final product doesn't exceed what you get at a standard supermarket. Attempted to contact to ask if maybe there was a bad batch I received but never heard from them. The no response and average product make it difficult to find a reason to attempt them again. Overall, not satisfied with the taste or service.

img 2/5.0 13, Jul 2023

Poor Value Compared to Local Butchers

I thought it would be an easy upgrade from locally purchased meat to try a premium meat delivery company such as Mr. Steak. But after my order arrived, it was apparent the value wasn't there. The cuts were diminutive compared to what I expect and lacked both the flavor and the marbling I'm used to getting from my local butcher, who costs less and is more transparent. The shipping was on time, though, the experience was not worth the money. Grilling the steaks did not change things either?they were not tender enough as I had expected and failed to deliver on the gourmet flavor advertised. The online advertising sets high hopes which were not met in the product. For what we paid, I expected a certain level of luxury and consistency which we did not find. Would not suggest this to someone who has access to good butchers in town. It's hype over substance, and there are better methods to spend money on this type of meat.

img 1/5.0 10, Jul 2023

Lack of Transparency in Sourcing

Selected Mr. Steak based on assertions of obtaining high-quality, ethically raised beef from quality ranches. But through further research and investigation, discovered that certain information regarding sourcing methods and ranch alliances was not present. Transparency matters when it comes to food sourcing, particularly for consumers who are concerned with ethical and sustainable processes. The absence of comprehensive details created suspicions regarding the authenticity of the allegations and the quality of the meat. Reached out to customer support for clarification but got evasive answers that dodged the queries. With such a plethora of options in the premium meat delivery industry, it's frustrating to come across an organization that issues bold marketing promises but fails to follow through to substantiate them. With the price and branding, there should be more transparency about origin, how it is grown, and welfare of the animals. This experience has bred distrust of the company's words and a choice not to go back.

img 1/5.0 07, Jul 2023

Lack of Transparency in Sourcing

Selected Mr. Steak due to assertions of using high-quality, humanely raised beef from well-regarded ranches. Yet, after deeper investigation and questioning, discovered that detailed information regarding sourcing practices and ranch collaborations was missing. It is essential to have transparency regarding food sourcing, particularly for those who value ethical and sustainable operations. The absence of detailed information cast doubt on the validity of the claims and the true quality of the meat. Called customer service to get clarification but was given ambiguous answers that failed to answer the questions

img 2/5.0 04, Jul 2023

Subpar Packaging and Presentation

Received my Mr. Steak order and was right away worried about the packaging. The box felt cheap, and the insulation was insufficient for insuring the requisite temperature throughout the trip. When opened, discovered some of the vacuum-packed packages leaked, raising cross-contamination issues. The visual presentation of the meat was poor, with cuts looking randomly trimmed and without uniformity. Hoped for better standards of care and professionalism considering the premium naming and pricing. Reported these to customer service, but the reaction was unimpressive, with no replacement or refund being offered. The proper packing and presentation are critical for perishable items, and this experience has revealed serious deficiencies in Mr. Steak operations. Will not be ordering from Mr. Steak in the future and recommend that others explore alternative vendors who value quality and customer satisfaction.

img 1/5.0 01, Jul 2023

Misleading Product Descriptions

Purchased a variety pack from Mr. Steak, tempted by the descriptions of premium, grass-fed beef with excellent marbling. Upon receiving and cooking the steaks, discovered that the reality fell short of the descriptions. Meat did not have the proper marbling and tenderness assured, and thus was a disappointing dining experience. Felt deceived by the product descriptions and marketing that created expectations which could not be fulfilled. Reached out to customer service to bring the disparity to their attention, but the feedback was unsatisfactory with no resolution to rectify the issue. Honesty and openness about product descriptions are necessary to establish trust among customers. This experience has depleted trust in the offerings of Mr. Steak and prompted the pursuit of other providers who live up to their marketing claims. Potential clients need to proceed with care and control expectations in kind.

img 2/5.0 28, Jun 2023

Overpriced for the Quality

After receiving good reviews on Mr. Steak, chose to order despite the increased cost, anticipating superior quality. Ordered a variety of cuts, including filets and ribeyes. Cooked and tasted the steaks, finding them to be only average at best, with none of the tenderness and flavor one would expect from a premium source. Given the price, the quality was not worth the cost. Equally good or better-quality steaks can be obtained at local butchers or supermarkets for a small fraction of the cost. Moreover, the portion sizes were smaller than anticipated, which further reduced the value. Reached out to customer service to report concerns, but the response was aloof and did not provide any type of compensation or resolution. This experience has resulted in disappointment and a choice not to reorder. For people looking for quality steaks, it might be better to look at local alternatives that provide better value for money and similar, if not superior, quality.

img 1/5.0 25, Jun 2023

Unresponsive Customer Service

Ordered Mr. Steak and was disappointed by various issues such as late delivery and issues related to meat quality on arrival. Made repeated efforts to reach customer service through email and phone to resolve these issues. Unfortunately, got no response or confirmation of my queries. The communication breakdown and lack of support were highly frustrating, considering the premium quality of the products and the company's assertion of outstanding service. As a consumer, I anticipate prompt and effective communication, especially when handling perishable items. The lack of customer support made me doubt the reliability and professionalism of Mr. Steak. From this experience, I am hesitant to order from them in the future and cannot recommend their services. Businesses that focus on customer satisfaction and timely support are crucial, particularly in the food delivery business. Mr. Steak's inability in this matter has cost them my trust and confidence in their brand.

img 2/5.0 22, Jun 2023

Inconsistent Steak Thickness

Ordered a number of cuts from Mr. Steak, ribeyes and sirloins, hoping for consistency and quality. Upon opening, found that the steaks were quite inconsistent in thickness, making it difficult to cook them evenly. Certain pieces were significantly thinner than others, leading to burnt edges and raw centers. This unevenness impacted the overall experience and did not match the premium price of the products. Complained to customer service about the problem, but the reply was bland and didn't provide an acceptable solution. Consistency is critical where premium meats are involved, and this experience was a disappointment. While flavor was tolerable, inability to get consistent cooking because of the difference in thicknesses was disappointing. Looked for higher levels of detail and quality control from a company dedicated to delivering steaks. Will look into alternative providers who are able to offer consistency and improved overall experience.

img 1/5.0 19, Jun 2023

Quality Issues with the Meat

Decided to give Mr. Steak a try due to the good reviews and the fact that high-quality meat would be shipped to my doorstep. Bought a mix of cuts, ribeyes and filets. The meat was discolored when it arrived and had an unpleasant smell. Despite this, I decided to prepare one of the steaks in order to gauge the taste and texture. Sadly, the steak was hard, flavorless, and did not live up to the quality standards I associate with a premium meat provider. Contacted customer service to let them know how unhappy I was and ask if there was a refund or replacement. Underwhelming response with no attempt to resolve the issue. Disappointed by this experience and questioning why all the reviews were so glowing. For the cost incurred, I expected better quality and service. Unfortunately, I would not be able to recommend Mr. Steak from this experience and shall be looking for other meat delivery services which emphasize product quality and customer satisfaction.

img 2/5.0 16, Jun 2023

Delivery Delays and Poor Packaging

Placed an order for a variety of steaks for a family event, anticipating timely delivery as advertised. The package came two days later than expected, which was highly inconvenient. On opening, I found that the dry ice had evaporated fully, and the meat was not at a safe temperature anymore. The packaging was not adequate for sustaining the required cold temperatures while in transit. Called customer service, but the turnaround was slow, and a replacement was not provided. Was forced to throw away the entire order because of safety issues, resulting in wasted money and failed expectations. With the premium price tag, I expected greater service and reliability. This has left me hesitant to order again, as on-time delivery and adequate packaging are important when working with perishable products. Logistics and customer service must be improved to maintain customer satisfaction.

img 5/5.0 13, Jun 2023

Made a Memorable Meal

Used Mr. Steak for family dinner and everyone loved it. People were continually asking where the steak was sourced. The flavor and tenderness were impressive from the very start. Shipping was a breeze and packaging worked just fine.

img 4/5.0 10, Jun 2023

Happy With My Order

Placed first order last month and was thoroughly impressed with the whole experience. The meat was delivered as promised and was more flavorful than most seen at local supermarkets. Will definitely order another soon.

img 5/5.0 07, Jun 2023

Effortless and Delicious

All the way from the website to the delivery, it was seamless. Steak was fresh and cold. Seasoned with a little bit and it came out divine. Extremely satisfied with how easy they make it to have nice meat at home.

img 4/5.0 04, Jun 2023

Great Meat for the Price

It's more expensive than buying in the store, but the quality is worth it. Tried the filet and ribeye and both were great. Flavorful, juicy, and cooked perfectly. Packaging was sturdy enough to withstand shipping.

img 5/5.0 01, Jun 2023

High-Caliber Cuts

You can taste the quality difference with Mr. Steak. The cuts are premium feeling, and there is no excess fat or gristle. Cooked rare and the texture was perfect. Good communication regarding shipping status helped as well.

img 4/5.0 29, May 2023

Strong Marbling and Flavor

The marbling on their steaks is not to be underestimated. The ribeye grilled was great with even fat distribution and remained moist during cooking. Much better than average grocery store fare. Delivery service was good and arrived on time.

img 5/5.0 26, May 2023

Great Gift Idea

Sent a meat box to a relative for their birthday and they loved it. The meat cuts were of the highest quality and results when grilled were superb. It's an excellent suggestion for someone who loves to cook or barbecue. Satisfied with the experience in general.

img 4/5.0 23, May 2023

Grilling Just Got Better

These steaks make grilling a luxury. Tried several different cuts and all were juicy and flavorful. They are best on high heat and sear well on cast iron or grill. Shipping was quick and packaging was sturdy.

img 5/5.0 20, May 2023

Solid First Experience

Purchased a small box to experiment, and glad that it was done. Meat arrived on schedule and in excellent condition. Prepared a porterhouse and it had tremendous flavor. Not too fatty, just nicely balanced. Will definitely order again.

img 4/5.0 17, May 2023

Just the Right Thickness

Easily find store steaks too thin or uneven, but Mr. Steak's steaks were ideally thick for grilling. Very good balance between fat and lean meat. Was well-packaged and arrived fine with no problems shipping. Truly a better choice for meat delivery.

img 5/5.0 14, May 2023

Restaurant Quality at Home

Having a steak night at home was like eating at an upscale steakhouse. The portions were big and the taste was great. It was a wonderful evening with friends and many compliments. Everything came cold and on time.

img 4/5.0 11, May 2023

Easy to Cook and Enjoy

Grilled the filet mignon with some simple seasoning and it didn't require much more. The quality of the meat is self-evident. It cooked uniformly and had a good finish. Enjoy the simple packaging and delivery as well.

img 5/5.0 08, May 2023

Better Than the Butcher

Have purchased meat from local butchers for years, but Mr. Steak brought something better. Their ribeyes were rich and tender, never before experienced. Even a finicky steak eater was impressed. Definitely returning for more.

img 4/5.0 05, May 2023

Dependable Meat Delivery

This was the third purchase from Mr. Steak and it was just as good as the first two. Quality has not changed and the cuts are always clean and well-trimmed. Enjoy the attention to detail and speed of service. Makes home cooking easier.

img 5/5.0 02, May 2023

Flavorful and Well-Handled

Ordered a box to try the service and was pleased with the outcome. The steak was full of good flavor and texture, with definite marbling and no unpleasant odors. Shipping was quick, and packaging maintained freshness. Grilled to medium-rare and turned out fine.

img 4/5.0 29, Apr 2023

Nice Upgrade for the Grill

Tried the T-bone steak on a new grill and was impressed. The meat was resistant to high heat and was full of flavor. Delivery was efficient and the meat remained cold during transit. Good option if looking to upgrade the grill game.

img 5/5.0 26, Apr 2023

Perfect for Special Dinners

Received a sampler box for a home anniversary dinner. Each cut was superb, particularly the ribeye. It was perfectly marbled and had a beautiful sear. The steaks were obviously aged to perfection and cooked uniformly. Excellent experience overall.

img 4/5.0 23, Apr 2023

Surprising Quality Online

Didn't know what to anticipate from buying meat online, but Mr. Steak did not disappoint. Strip steak had a good fat cap and seared nicely on the grill. Slightly more expensive than the grocery store, but the outcome was much better.

img 5/5.0 20, Apr 2023

Excellent Customer Experience

Customer service responded when there was an issue regarding the order. The steaks were superior quality and included good handling instructions. Grilled them on a Mr. Steak infrared grill and they turned out nicely. Everything regarding the experience was well planned.

img 4/5.0 17, Apr 2023

Great for Entertaining

Purchased a couple of cuts for a weekend barbeque and the guests could not stop admiring the food. The meat grilled perfectly and retained its juiciness. Even the burgers were significantly better than normal. Will surely take Mr. Steak into consideration for future events.

img 5/5.0 14, Apr 2023

Worth the Price Tag

These steaks are pricey, but the quality is well worth it. The filet mignon was buttery, tender, and packed with flavor. You can tell these cuts are from quality sources. Delivery was on time and well-packaged, and overall service was seamless.

img 4/5.0 11, Apr 2023

Freshness Was Noticeable

You can really taste the freshness of their steaks. Grilled a New York strip and it was juicy and full of flavor. The vacuum-sealed packaging worked well and the delivery came within the expected timeframe. It?s a nice upgrade from what I?m used to buying locally.

img 5/5.0 08, Apr 2023

Smooth Process and Great Taste

The ordering process was easy, and the meat came in great shape. The first sirloin attempted had a great texture and cooked spot-on. Packaging was great at keeping things cold and safe. A much more upscale experience than the local butchers or chain shops.

img 4/5.0 05, Apr 2023

Very Pleased with the Flavor

Ordered a couple of ribeyes to test out their service, and they did not let us down. The taste was deep and rich, and the marbling on the steaks was spot on. On-time delivery and everything cold when it arrived. A good choice for meat lovers looking for more than the fundamentals.

img 5/5.0 02, Apr 2023

Quality Beyond Expectations

The steaks came nicely wrapped and were very fresh. The grade was truly wonderful, much higher than what you find in the supermarket. The meat was tender and grilled to perfection. You can tell they take pride in what they send out. Will use Mr. Steak again when hosting a family meal.

Mr. Steak

Address
833.MRSTEAK
United States

Website
mrsteak.com

Email
liz@mrsteak.com

Telephone

People who looked at this companies also looked at
Recent Posts

Sign In