Fish For Skeptics
4.05/5.0
Kevin Bryant
5/5.0
13, Sep 2025
Great for healthy eating
Adding their salmon and cod to my diet has made eating healthy much easier. The fillets are lean, flavorful, and simple to prepare. Delivery has been consistent, and I like being able to track my box. It?s a convenient way to maintain better eating habits without sacrificing taste.
Adam Stewart
5/5.0
03, Sep 2025
Family-friendly portions
Portions are generous and balanced for dinner prep. The salmon was tasty and flaky. The ability to change delivery frequency easily is a big plus. Consistently reliable service.
Joshua Harris
1/5.0
30, Aug 2025
Very underwhelming experience
The salmon tasted bland and lacked the freshness I was expecting. Delivery updates were unclear, and customer service didn?t respond quickly when I reached out. Overall, it felt like a waste of money. I could have gotten similar quality from my local store for less.
Vincent Butler
5/5.0
25, Aug 2025
A pleasant surprise
I wasn?t sure how online seafood delivery would work out, but everything arrived frozen and perfectly portioned. The char was new to me, and I loved the rich flavor. Customer service followed up to make sure I was satisfied. That extra touch really made me feel valued.
Jeremy Carr
5/5.0
14, Aug 2025
A lifesaver for busy weeks
I don?t always have time to shop for fresh fish, so this service has been a game-changer. The cod fillets were mild and perfect for simple weeknight meals. Each one was portioned and sealed, which made thawing quick and easy. Delivery was on time, and the tracking system kept me updated. I love that I can pause or adjust my subscription whenever I need. It?s flexible, reliable, and most importantly, the seafood is truly top quality.
Peter Collins
4/5.0
09, Aug 2025
Solid overall experience
Great variety and option to customize boxes. Delivery was smooth, arrived frozen even in the heat. Only suggestion: a small guide on ideal cooking times, but quality is excellent.
Tristan Bishop
2/5.0
31, Jul 2025
Customer service frustrating
My box was delayed, and when I reached out, the response felt dismissive. They offered credit, but I?d rather have a quick refund. It left a sour impression.
Douglas Edwards
3/5.0
20, Jul 2025
Overpriced for what you get
I liked that the seafood was traceable, but when I compared it to what I can buy locally, the difference in quality wasn?t huge. The convenience of delivery is nice, but not enough to justify the cost. The box was fine, but nothing exceptional. If they offered a wider variety of seafood or better value, it might be worth it. As it stands, I felt like I paid more for the story than the product.
Amanda White
5/5.0
16, Jul 2025
Consistently fresh
I?ve tried different options, but this one stands out for consistent freshness. The halibut had a buttery texture and cooked wonderfully. I also liked the transparency about sourcing, it makes me trust the product more. I feel confident serving this to my family without second-guessing quality.
Carl Simmons
4/5.0
08, Jul 2025
Good, but could expand options
The salmon was excellent, and delivery was smooth. I only wish they offered more types of seafood like shrimp or scallops. Still, what I received was high quality, flavorful, and neatly packaged. The sustainability focus is reassuring. Overall, a positive experience worth recommending to others.
Noah Patterson
5/5.0
28, Jun 2025
Perfect for meal prep
I portioned out the cod and salmon for weekly lunches, and it was perfect. The fish thawed without losing texture and cooked evenly every time. I appreciate that the packaging is compact and freezer-friendly. Freshness was consistent across all fillets. Great option for people who plan ahead like me.
Madison Gonzalez
4/5.0
22, Jun 2025
Tasty and easy
The cod was mild and flaky, exactly what I like. It was super easy to prepare for a quick dinner. Delivery came right on time, and everything was still rock solid. A little pricey, but the quality made me feel like it was money well spent.
Henry Evans
2/5.0
07, Jun 2025
Not as fresh as expected
The advertising emphasizes freshness, but my shipment didn?t quite match that promise. A couple of the fillets looked discolored after thawing and didn?t smell as clean as I?d expect. I cooked them anyway, but the taste wasn?t great. For something shipped at a premium price, I expected restaurant-quality seafood, and this fell short. The concept is nice, but execution is inconsistent. Unless quality control improves, I won?t continue with the subscription.
Marcus Fields
4/5.0
04, Jun 2025
Fresh and reliable
The Arctic char I received was excellent. It was a new type of fish for me, but it quickly became a favorite. The packaging was solid, with insulation that kept everything frozen even though my area had high temperatures. Delivery was reliable, and the traceability information made me confident in the source. The only thing I would change is having more variety of seafood options. Still, I really liked the freshness and convenience this service offers.
Aaron Parker
5/5.0
30, May 2025
Supports sustainability
As someone conscious about seafood sourcing, I loved the transparency and antibiotic-free claim. Taste and texture did not disappoint. A reliable and conscientious choice.
Julian Elliott
5/5.0
21, May 2025
Great taste and great service
I tried their subscription box for the first time, and I?m so glad I did. The salmon tasted amazing, moist, flavorful, and cooked evenly in the oven. Each fillet was vacuum-packed, which kept my freezer organized. I was also impressed with the quick delivery and the way the company communicates updates. Customer service followed up to make sure I was satisfied, which I really appreciated. Overall, it felt like a premium service that genuinely values customer satisfaction.
Ethan Foster
5/5.0
15, May 2025
Consistently good experience
I?ve tried three boxes now, and each has been great. The fish is always vacuum-packed, easy to store, and tastes clean. Delivery has been consistent, even during warm weather. It?s reassuring to have a dependable source of quality seafood without running to multiple stores. Highly recommend their subscription.
Benjamin Turner
2/5.0
11, May 2025
Packaging not strong enough
The fish was decent, but the packaging wasn?t sturdy. One of the vacuum seals broke, and liquid leaked into the box. It made me nervous about food safety. For the cost, I expected better handling. The idea is good, but execution really fell short here.
Olivia Mitchell
5/5.0
27, Apr 2025
Excellent packaging
The fish arrived perfectly frozen thanks to solid packaging. I appreciated how easy it was to store everything in the freezer. The salmon fillets were especially good, rich flavor and cooked evenly. For someone who enjoys seafood a few times a week, this service is really convenient.
Tyler Campbell
4/5.0
18, Apr 2025
Convenient and fresh
Perfect for those busy nights, I just defrost, season, and grill. Delivery was reliable and packaging protective. Could offer more spice blends, but the fish stands strong on its own.
Maxwell Chapman
5/5.0
12, Apr 2025
Better than grocery store seafood
I used to buy frozen fish at the supermarket, but the difference with this service is huge. The salmon fillets were fresh, bright in color, and had zero fishy smell. Packaging was professional, and each portion was perfect for a single meal. Delivery was smooth, and I never had to worry about the fish thawing. For the convenience of having high-quality seafood on hand without guesswork, this is by far the better option. I?ll continue ordering regularly.
Sean Ross
3/5.0
06, Apr 2025
Hit or miss
My first box was fantastic, perfectly frozen, delicious fish. The second had some fillets with odd texture. I don?t like inconsistency, especially for something this expensive. Might cancel if it happens again.
Bryce Stevens
5/5.0
31, Mar 2025
Smooth process from start to finish
I?ve had other food subscriptions, but this one stands out. Ordering was simple, the tracking was accurate, and the box arrived right on time. The cod fillets were individually sealed, which was great for freezing and thawing only what I needed. I cooked them with just lemon and herbs, and they tasted amazing, clean, mild, and flaky. I love knowing that the fish is sourced responsibly. For me, this has been a stress-free way to keep healthy meals on hand.
Christian Long
2/5.0
22, Mar 2025
Packaging didn?t hold up
The box looked damaged when it arrived, and one pack of cod had leaked. While other portions were fine, I wasn?t comfortable cooking the damaged one. They refunded partially, but the hassle wasn?t worth it.
Matthew Thomas
4/5.0
17, Mar 2025
Satisfied with quality
I?ve ordered twice now, and both times the fish arrived in good condition. The taste is clean and fresh, exactly what I hoped for. My only critique is the limited variety at times, but what they do offer has been excellent quality so far. I recommend it.
Jerry Phillips
5/5.0
10, Mar 2025
Loved the char
Arctic char had an amazing texture, moist but flaky. I appreciated the detailed tracking and the ease of skipping shipments when needed. Great taste, minimal fuss.
Ashley Taylor
5/5.0
25, Feb 2025
Great for meal planning
I enjoy having high-quality seafood stocked in the freezer. The portions make meal prep simple, and the flavor is far better than what I find locally. Delivery was smooth, and the eco-friendly approach makes me feel better about my purchase. I?ll definitely reorder again soon.
Dennis Turner
4/5.0
22, Feb 2025
High-quality seafood
The fish was noticeably better than what I get at the supermarket. Well-sealed for freshness, clean taste. 4 stars because pricing is a little higher, but understandable for sustainable sourcing.
Leonardo Arnold
2/5.0
18, Feb 2025
Billing issue
I got charged twice for the same order. It took multiple emails to fix, which was stressful. The seafood was decent, but that error really hurt trust.
Elijah Sanders
4/5.0
09, Feb 2025
Reliable and tasty
My order came on time, packed in thick insulation. The salmon was mild and moist, perfect for pan-searing. Customer service was polite when I asked about cooking suggestions. The only reason I gave 4 instead of 5 stars is the limited selection. Still, a very reliable service overall.
Daniel Moore
4/5.0
29, Jan 2025
Nice alternative to store-bought
I usually buy fish at the supermarket, but this was a step above. The Arctic char was delicious, and everything arrived frozen solid. Customer service was quick when I had a small question. It?s more expensive, but the freshness and convenience make it worth it.
Austin Price
5/5.0
22, Jan 2025
Impressive freshness
I live in a hot climate and worried about seafood shipping, but the box arrived frozen solid. The cod had a delicate, mild flavor, and the portions were easy to work with. Tracking updates kept me informed throughout. Overall, the freshness really impressed me, and I?ll be ordering again.
Jack Roberts
5/5.0
13, Jan 2025
Effortless excellence
Everything from placing the order to delivery was seamless. The fish tasted fresh and delicate, and thawed beautifully without texture issues. Excellent customer experience from start to finish.
Dominic Fisher
4/5.0
04, Jan 2025
Solid experience overall
I ordered salmon and char, and both were excellent. The salmon was moist and flavorful, while the char had a rich taste I hadn?t tried before. The box arrived a bit later in the day than I expected, but everything inside was perfectly frozen and sealed. I liked the clear instructions for storage and defrosting, which made things easier. The pricing is fair considering the quality, and I?m happy with the overall experience. Definitely worth trying again.
Xavier Jordan
5/5.0
27, Dec 2024
Convenient and trustworthy
As someone who meal preps regularly, having reliable seafood delivered to my door is a huge help. The cod fillets were fresh, firm, and portioned so well that cooking was simple. I appreciated the detailed delivery tracking, which kept me updated until the box arrived. The fish was still solidly frozen despite a long travel distance. I also like how this company is transparent about sourcing. It?s rare to find both quality and trust combined so consistently.
Raymond Perez
4/5.0
19, Dec 2024
Flexible boxes are great
I like being able to mix salmon and cod in one box. Ordering next time was smooth and intuitive. Only minor gripe is that I?d like some recipe inspiration, but fish quality is stellar.
Joseph Perez
5/5.0
14, Dec 2024
Very reliable service
Every order so far has arrived on time and perfectly packed. I love being able to trace where the fish comes from. It gives me confidence in what I?m eating. The cod and salmon have been consistently good quality. I?ll happily continue ordering regularly from them.
Juan Hughes
5/5.0
05, Dec 2024
Smooth process and tasty fish
From ordering to delivery, everything went smoothly. The seafood was packed perfectly, and the salmon cooked beautifully in the oven. The vacuum-sealed packaging is a lifesaver for meal planning. I also appreciate their eco-friendly approach. This is a service I can see myself sticking with for the long term.
Alan James
3/5.0
28, Nov 2024
Good fish, weak support
The salmon was tasty, but I had an issue with billing that took far too long to resolve. Customer service replies were slow and generic. I expected better when paying a premium price for seafood.
Wesley West
3/5.0
20, Nov 2024
Not what I expected
I was excited to try the Arctic char, but the taste wasn?t as fresh as described. The fillets cooked fine, but didn?t feel premium. It?s okay, just not amazing.
Hannah Carter
4/5.0
09, Nov 2024
Good value overall
The seafood quality was great, and I liked the variety offered. My favorite was the halibut, it was mild and flaky. Shipping was smooth, though I wish portion sizes were a bit larger. Overall, it?s a good option for convenient and responsibly sourced fish at home.
Alexander Mitchell
3/5.0
06, Nov 2024
Customer service needs improvement
While the fish tasted good, dealing with their customer service was frustrating. I had a billing issue where I was charged twice, and it took multiple messages over several days to get it sorted. When you?re running a subscription service, mistakes happen, but the resolution process should be smoother. I ended up feeling like I was inconveniencing them for asking for a refund. It really soured what could have been a positive seafood experience.
Patrick Carter
2/5.0
24, Oct 2024
Portion sizes too small
I was expecting family-friendly portions based on the description, but what arrived was smaller than expected. Some pieces were barely enough for one adult serving. For the cost, I felt underwhelmed. Taste was decent, but the value wasn?t there. It didn?t feel like a good balance between price and portion size. If they adjusted serving sizes or lowered the price, I?d reconsider. Right now, I don?t feel the box justifies its premium positioning.
Sarah Wilson
5/5.0
21, Oct 2024
Fresh and tasty
I was really impressed with the freshness of the salmon. It cooked beautifully and had a clean flavor. Delivery was on time, and the packaging kept everything frozen solid. Definitely a reliable option for quality seafood without having to hunt it down in local stores.
Adrian Stone
5/5.0
16, Oct 2024
Restaurant quality at home
I ordered Arctic char for the first time and it tasted just like a dish from a fine dining restaurant. The fish was rich, flaky, and cooked beautifully on the grill. The packaging was impressive, keeping everything perfectly frozen and organized. I enjoyed how convenient the delivery process was, I didn?t have to run to multiple stores looking for decent seafood. Knowing that it?s sustainably sourced makes me feel better too. It?s the best way to elevate home cooking.
Logan Ramirez
4/5.0
11, Oct 2024
Great for family dinners
I used the salmon to prepare grilled fillets for my family, and everyone loved it. The portions were generous and evenly cut, making cooking easy. Shipping was quick, and the packaging was sturdy. Slightly more expensive than supermarket options, but the freshness and flavor make it worthwhile for us.
Christopher Miller
1/5.0
30, Sep 2024
Disappointed with quality
I had high hopes, but the Arctic char I received didn?t taste fresh. The texture was mushy, and I wasn?t impressed at all. Customer support offered little help when I reported it. Considering the premium price, the value wasn?t there. Definitely not ordering again.
Gabriel Gray
5/5.0
25, Sep 2024
Excellent quality every time
I?ve had three orders so far, and the consistency is what impresses me most. Each time, the fish arrives frozen solid, with vacuum-sealed portions that make meal prep easy. The taste is noticeably fresher than store-bought frozen fish. Their traceability info adds extra confidence in what I?m eating.
Samuel Nelson
5/5.0
12, Sep 2024
Restaurant quality at home
Fillets were restaurant-grade, firm, flavorful, and perfectly portioned. Simple prep, beautiful results. I was impressed by their attention to sustainable sourcing. A go-to for family dinners now.
Seth Dean
5/5.0
06, Sep 2024
Best seafood delivery I?ve tried
I wasn?t sure what to expect, but this exceeded my expectations. The salmon fillets were thick, fresh, and vacuum-sealed, making freezer storage simple. Everything arrived on time, completely frozen despite the summer heat. Cooking them was effortless, and the flavor was outstanding, better than anything I?ve bought locally. I also loved seeing the traceability information that showed exactly where the fish came from. It gave me extra confidence in what I was serving my family. Excellent service all around.
Gregory Baker
4/5.0
27, Aug 2024
Remarkably fresh
Even though delivery was in hot weather, the seafood arrived still frozen solid. Cod came out tender, and my kids loved it. Maybe offer a cold-pack upgrade for extra-hot days, but overall fantastic.
Cameron Graham
5/5.0
19, Aug 2024
Excellent overall experience
Everything about my first order went smoothly. From the clear ordering process to the fast delivery, it was easy. The fish was tasty, fresh, and easy to cook. I especially liked being able to see where it was sourced. A trustworthy service I?d be happy to recommend.
Jason Baker
2/5.0
13, Aug 2024
Delivery delay ruined the plan
My order arrived two days late, and the fish was starting to thaw. I expected reliable shipping given the price. While the taste was fine, the whole experience was stressful. I probably won?t risk ordering again since freshness should never be questionable with seafood delivery.
Willie Peterson
4/5.0
02, Aug 2024
Good variety and flexibility
I like being able to mix different fish types in one box. The cod and salmon were both excellent, with clean taste and no fishy smell. Delivery was straightforward, and everything stayed frozen. The flexibility to pause shipments is very convenient, especially when my schedule changes. A solid service.
Blake Hamilton
4/5.0
29, Jul 2024
Worth trying
I was pleasantly surprised by the taste and freshness of the cod. Delivery arrived as scheduled, and the insulation worked well. I only give 4 stars because the box is a bit bulky to store, but overall, the quality was impressive. Definitely worth trying at least once.
Emily Davis
5/5.0
23, Jul 2024
Excellent seafood subscription
I signed up for the subscription, and so far every box has been impressive. The cod and salmon are consistently high quality, flavorful, and easy to cook. The packaging is neat, compact, and reliable for freezer storage. Delivery is always on time, and I love how I can pause or adjust shipments whenever I need. For me, the best part is not worrying about freshness, it?s always reliable. This has been a fantastic experience from day one.
Albert Torres
5/5.0
15, Jul 2024
Restaurant-quality seafood
I cooked the Arctic char for dinner guests, and everyone thought it tasted like something from a nice restaurant. The fish was buttery and cooked evenly. Delivery was smooth, and the packaging was professional. I feel better knowing it?s antibiotic-free and responsibly sourced. This service really exceeded my expectations.
Benjamin Adams
5/5.0
09, Jul 2024
Subscription made simple
Signing up for a subscription was easy, and I could pause it mid-month hassle-free. The fish stayed fresh in transit and tasted light and clean. Will keep using this service.
Bruce Flores
5/5.0
26, Jun 2024
Great balance of quality and service
This was my first time ordering seafood online, and I was skeptical. The salmon and cod both turned out delicious. The ordering process was simple, the tracking was accurate, and the box arrived frozen. I like the company?s sustainability approach. Customer service was helpful when I asked about recipes.
Frank Hill
4/5.0
18, Jun 2024
Great taste, minimal waste
Love the no-waste portions, they fit in small pans and don?t overcook. Quality is consistently good. Wish they offered a few seasoning packets, but that?s besides the point, delightful product.
Nathaniel Ford
3/5.0
14, Jun 2024
Okay experience
Fish quality was fine, but not outstanding. Packaging was solid, but there was little variety available. It?s not bad, but it?s not something I?d stick with long term.
David Johnson
5/5.0
09, Jun 2024
Great for healthy living
I?ve been trying to eat healthier, and this service made it so much easier. The salmon fillets were portioned perfectly for meal prep, and they tasted incredible, fresh, moist, and not overly strong. Delivery was smooth, and everything was still frozen when it arrived. I also appreciate that the packaging is easy to recycle. Knowing the fish is antibiotic-free makes me feel even better about eating it. This service really supports my healthy lifestyle in a convenient way.
Brandon Nguyen
5/5.0
31, May 2024
Trustworthy seafood
The traceability feature is a standout, I could see the harvest date and location. The cod tasted fresh and sweet. Excellent value for responsibly sourced fish. I appreciate that transparency.
Stella Lopez
5/5.0
25, May 2024
Better than expected
I tried the salmon and was impressed by how fresh and flavorful it was. The packaging kept everything frozen, even though my area had a delivery delay due to weather. Each fillet cooked evenly, with a moist and flaky texture. The traceability feature was interesting and reassuring. I liked being able to see where the fish was caught. It gave me confidence in the product. Overall, this was better than expected, and I?ll definitely order again.
Billy Ward
4/5.0
18, May 2024
Reliable seafood delivery
The Arctic char was delicious, mild and flaky without being dry. Packaging was sturdy, and the insulation kept everything frozen despite the summer heat. My only minor issue was the box arriving later in the day, but freshness was unaffected. Overall, I?m impressed with both the quality and reliability.
Connor Myers
5/5.0
07, May 2024
Fresh seafood made simple
I used the salmon for a quick dinner, and it was both flavorful and satisfying. The portions were just right, and the packaging kept everything perfectly preserved. I liked how easy it was to defrost and cook. This service takes the stress out of buying good seafood.
Caleb Hayes
5/5.0
25, Apr 2024
Loved the packaging
Each fillet was vacuum-sealed and labeled, making freezer storage super easy. I tried the salmon first and it was flaky, moist, and full of flavor. Delivery was right on time, and the tracking info was accurate. This was a smooth and pleasant experience overall. Highly recommend.
Justin Torres
3/5.0
20, Apr 2024
Inconsistent experiences
I?ve ordered twice, and the results were mixed. First box came perfectly frozen and delicious. Second box, however, had some soft spots in the fillets, and I wasn?t sure about the freshness. While they do offer a ?happiness guarantee,? the back-and-forth emails to get a replacement took more effort than I wanted. I like the mission of sustainable seafood, but inconsistency makes it hard to trust. Reliability is crucial for me with seafood.
Jordan Howard
5/5.0
15, Apr 2024
Perfect for quick meals
Having individually sealed fillets in the freezer makes weeknight dinners so much easier. The cod was firm, clean tasting, and portioned perfectly. Delivery came on schedule, and everything was still frozen solid. I love that I can adjust my subscription whenever I want. It?s convenience with quality.
Lucas Henderson
5/5.0
04, Apr 2024
Delicious and easy
I loved how easy it was to prepare the cod fillets. They defrosted quickly without losing texture, and the flavor was mild but satisfying. Delivery was seamless, and everything was labeled and packaged in a very user-friendly way. It felt like a thoughtful process from beginning to end. I also appreciated that they prioritize sustainability, it?s something that matters to me. The combination of quality, convenience, and responsible sourcing makes this service stand out above the rest.
Joe Cox
5/5.0
29, Mar 2024
Freshness exceeded expectations
I was honestly surprised at how fresh the salmon tasted after being shipped. Each portion was vacuum-sealed and easy to store in the freezer. Cooking it was simple, and the flavor was far better than supermarket fish. Delivery was on time, and the traceability feature gave me confidence in the source.
Paige Stewart
2/5.0
20, Mar 2024
Poor handling of thawing
One shipment arrived with fish slightly thawed. They apologized, but the credit offered didn?t feel like enough. I lost confidence in ordering perishable items from them.
Isaiah Diaz
3/5.0
13, Mar 2024
Pricey for the value
I liked the traceability aspect, but the fish didn?t taste much better than what I buy locally at half the price. Delivery was fine, but the value wasn?t there.
Larry Scott
2/5.0
08, Mar 2024
Packaging problem
The idea is great, but execution fell short. My delivery box arrived with one corner torn open, and a couple of vacuum-sealed packs had small leaks. I was worried about food safety and ended up tossing them. Customer service offered a credit, but it took over a week to process. For a perishable item, speed is everything. The cod that was intact tasted nice, but dealing with packaging failures makes me think twice about reordering.
Lucas Griffin
4/5.0
28, Feb 2024
Tasty fish, smooth delivery
The cod arrived in perfect condition, with each fillet portioned out. It cooked evenly and tasted fresh. I liked being able to track the box as it shipped. My only wish is for slightly larger serving sizes. Otherwise, it was an enjoyable and convenient seafood experience.
Stephen Wright
4/5.0
15, Feb 2024
Thoughtful packaging
The vacuum-sealed pieces arrived in sturdy, insulated packaging that kept everything perfectly frozen. Thawed beautifully. Slight delay by one day, but freshness was intact. Quality still homely and reliable.
Jessica Brown
5/5.0
09, Feb 2024
Great option for families
I ordered a box of salmon, and it worked perfectly for family dinners. The portions were just the right size, and the flavor was fresh and mild enough for the kids to enjoy. Everything arrived frozen solid and vacuum-packed, making it easy to store. Delivery was timely, and I liked the transparency about sourcing. Knowing where the fish came from made me feel good about serving it. This has been such a convenient way to plan healthy meals.
Bryan Richardson
2/5.0
05, Feb 2024
Delivery took too long
My order arrived two days later than promised. While the fish was still cold, I was uneasy about eating seafood that had partially thawed. The concept is good, but reliability is key with perishable food. Not sure I?ll continue.
Jesse Cooper
5/5.0
20, Jan 2024
Simply delicious and easy
Every time I cook the fish, it turns out moist and flavorful. Order flow is intuitive, and deliveries are punctual. A dependable way to enjoy high-quality seafood at home.
Michael Anderson
5/5.0
16, Jan 2024
Impressive from start to finish
Everything about my order went smoothly. The Arctic char was delicious, with a rich, buttery flavor that made it perfect for grilling. The packaging was professional and easy to store, and the delivery arrived exactly when expected. I appreciated the clear communication throughout the process. It felt like a premium service without being overly complicated. The best part is the fish tastes better than most restaurants. For me, this has been an amazing discovery and worth every penny.
Levi Bryant
5/5.0
11, Jan 2024
Great balance of convenience and taste
I enjoy cooking, but shopping for good seafood locally is tough. This solved that problem. The salmon was tender and flavorful, and the cod worked beautifully in recipes. The convenience of delivery and the trustworthy sourcing make it a clear winner for me. I?ll keep using it.
Eric King
5/5.0
06, Jan 2024
Perfect for busy cooks
These pre-portioned fillets are a lifesaver on hectic weeknights. Just season and bake, tender every time. Delivery was tracked and arrived on schedule. Love that I can customize the next box anytime.
Dylan Holland
5/5.0
28, Dec 2023
Consistently fresh and delicious
I?ve had several deliveries now, and the consistency impresses me every time. The cod and salmon always arrive perfectly frozen, sealed, and ready for the freezer. Cooking them has been simple, and the flavor is noticeably fresher than what I usually find locally. Delivery updates keep me informed, and the service feels very dependable. Having seafood this fresh available at home is a luxury I didn?t think was possible until now. Definitely sticking with this service long-term.
Nicholas Allen
4/5.0
23, Dec 2023
Good value, great quality
The portions are generous enough to feed a small family, and the quality feels premium, especially for direct-to-door delivery. Subscription pricing is fair. Only wish: a few more vegetarian prep suggestions in the newsletter.
Carter Coleman
5/5.0
16, Dec 2023
Straightforward and reliable
Ordering was simple, and the fish arrived exactly on time. The char had a buttery flavor and cooked evenly on the grill. I like that the packaging makes it easy to thaw only what I need. For someone busy, this service feels like a stress-free solution.
Dylan Rivera
4/5.0
08, Dec 2023
Great for meal prep
I prep meals ahead, and these portions freeze and thaw well without quality loss. Packaging is sturdy. Slightly high in price, but delivery convenience and quality justify it.
Owen Sullivan
2/5.0
30, Nov 2023
Small portions
The portion sizes are smaller than expected. What was supposed to be ?family-friendly? barely fed two adults. Flavor was fine, but I felt shortchanged for the price.
Lawrence Bailey
5/5.0
25, Nov 2023
Reliable seafood partner
No unpleasant odors, clean flavor, perfectly sealed. Customer support helped with a small schedule change immediately. Trustworthy service, will reorder.
Gary Young
5/5.0
11, Nov 2023
Amazing taste, zero drama
The Arctic char had a clean, fresh flavor, no fishy smell, just rich and buttery textures. Packaging kept it icy cold throughout transit. Customer support quickly answered my minor query. All in all, impressive service.
Corey Freeman
2/5.0
08, Nov 2023
Quality didn?t match hype
The marketing makes it sound top-tier, but honestly, the cod tasted no better than grocery store frozen fish. For the cost, I expected more. Disappointing.
Jacob Walker
5/5.0
29, Oct 2023
Seafood delivery done right
Ordered a subscription box of salmon, and it arrived promptly in perfect condition. I liked that I could pause the next shipment easily. Tasty, firm fillets that cooked up beautifullyjust what I wanted for quick meals.
Spencer Shaw
3/5.0
20, Oct 2023
Decent, but unreliable
Delivery timing is inconsistent?first box came on time, the second came a day late. Fish was still usable, but it makes me hesitate about relying on them.
Arthur Murphy
4/5.0
12, Oct 2023
Tasty and convenient
Preparing meals is easier with pre-portioned vacuum-sealed fillets. Taste is consistently fresh. A tiny complaint, the box is a bit bulky, but worth it for freshness.
Gavin Russell
3/5.0
07, Oct 2023
Good for families
The salmon portions were perfect for cooking for my family. Delivery was quick, and the packaging was secure. Everyone enjoyed the taste, it wasn?t too strong for the kids. I?d love to see more variety, but for now, the consistency and freshness keep me coming back.
Carl Bell
5/5.0
29, Sep 2023
Efficient delivery, excellent taste
Delivery was always on time and fish was properly frozen. The char melts in your mouth, it?s buttery and rich. Subscription flexibility is a major advantage.
Cole Perry
5/5.0
21, Sep 2023
Reliable seafood service
I?ve had seafood delivered twice now, and both times the quality has been excellent. The salmon was fresh and flavorful, with no unpleasant odor. The packaging kept everything frozen and organized. For someone who doesn?t have easy access to fresh seafood locally, this has been a game-changer.
Elliot Armstrong
5/5.0
17, Sep 2023
High-quality and sustainable
What drew me in initially was the sustainability factor, but the quality kept me coming back. The salmon fillets were flavorful, flaky, and cooked beautifully. Everything was packed carefully and arrived completely frozen. I like that each piece is sealed individually, it makes storing and portioning much easier. The traceability info gave me confidence that I?m eating responsibly sourced fish. It?s a win-win: delicious food that also supports better fishing practices. I?ll definitely continue using this service.
Ryan Robinson
4/5.0
07, Sep 2023
Sustainable and satisfying
Appreciate the sustainably sourced seafood and antibiotic-free promise. The portions are generous, and cooking was simple. Packaging was minimal but protective. Slightly pricey for some, but worth it for freshness and eco-friendly sourcing.
Dean Wallace
2/5.0
29, Aug 2023
Disappointed overall
I wanted to love this, but the fish was underwhelming, the portions were small, and shipping took too long. For the premium pricing, I expected a flawless experience. Didn?t get it.
Harold Morgan
4/5.0
24, Aug 2023
Good quality, small hiccup
Fish quality is always top notch, the cod cooks beautifully every time. I did have a packaging tear once, but customer service quickly followed up. Still highly satisfied.
Jeffrey Lewis
5/5.0
16, Aug 2023
Traceable quality
The tracking link showed exactly when the fish was harvested and shipped, awesome peace of mind. Everything arrived frozen solid and thawed beautifully. The char was especially flavorful. Excellent customer care and clear communication.
Hunter Jenkins
5/5.0
03, Aug 2023
Perfect for hosting dinners
I used the cod for a small dinner party, and it was a hit. Everyone commented on how fresh it tasted. The packaging made prep very easy, no mess or hassle. Delivery updates kept me informed the whole time. This service really makes entertaining at home less stressful.
Jason Ramirez
3/5.0
27, Jul 2023
Quality good, service lacking
The salmon itself was tasty and fresh, but the overall experience left me disappointed. My subscription order was processed late, and I didn?t receive clear tracking updates. I had to email twice before I got any useful response. When I?m paying a premium, I expect communication to be seamless. The fish was fine, but the hassle overshadowed the good. Unless they improve customer support, I?m hesitant to continue with regular orders.
Chase Powell
4/5.0
18, Jul 2023
Quality product, decent price
The char was very tasty, and the portions were well sized. Delivery came in a sturdy, insulated box. I think the price is reasonable for the quality you get. My only suggestion would be to expand shipping days so it?s easier to plan around. Otherwise, very happy so far.
Brady Warren
3/5.0
12, Jul 2023
Good idea, weak execution
Love the concept of sustainable seafood delivery, but customer experience needs polishing. Communication is slow, and shipments don?t always align with expected timelines. Quality is decent but inconsistent.
Kyle Cook
5/5.0
05, Jul 2023
Impressive traceability
I liked that I could trace where the seafood came from, it gave confidence in their claims. Taste and texture were premium. A dependable, and thoughtful, option for home cooks.
Oscar Barnes
5/5.0
30, Jun 2023
Excellent customer service
Not only was the fish delicious, but their customer support was excellent too. I had a small question about defrosting, and they responded quickly with detailed instructions. The salmon cooked up perfectly, moist and flavorful. The whole experience felt smooth and well thought out from start to finish.
Joel Simmons
4/5.0
23, Jun 2023
Good seafood subscription
This service has been very reliable so far. I?ve tried both cod and salmon, and they?ve been consistently tasty and easy to cook. The packaging was sturdy, and everything stayed frozen until I unpacked it. My only complaint is that shipping days could be more flexible, but otherwise, I?m happy. It?s a great option for people who want trustworthy seafood without worrying about freshness. I plan to keep my subscription because the convenience is hard to beat.
Walter Reed
3/5.0
13, Jun 2023
Too many hiccups
The seafood itself was decent, but the overall experience was filled with small frustrations. Tracking updates were delayed, one box arrived a day later than promised, and the support team was slow to reply. Each issue was minor on its own, but together, it left me feeling like the service wasn?t polished. For the premium they charge, I expected a hassle-free subscription. I don?t mind paying more for sustainable seafood, but not with this many headaches.
Edward Clark
2/5.0
09, Jun 2023
Delivery delays caused issues
I wanted to like this service because the idea of responsibly sourced seafood is appealing. Unfortunately, my order arrived two days late, and while the packaging kept most of it frozen, one portion had thawed. Customer service responded politely, but the resolution felt generic. For the price, I expected a smoother delivery and a more proactive solution. I may try again in the future, but this first experience didn?t inspire much confidence.
Zachary Rogers
2/5.0
27, May 2023
Poor follow-up on complaints
My order arrived partially thawed because of a courier delay, and while I understand that happens, the company?s follow-up was disappointing. They acknowledged the issue but didn?t offer a full refund, just a small credit for the next order. That assumes I want to order again, which I don?t. When dealing with perishable goods, they need to prioritize making things right, not offering half measures. The concept is appealing, but customer experience matters more.
Trevor Hart
5/5.0
19, May 2023
Great for entertaining
I hosted a dinner with friends and used the salmon fillets from my box. Everyone loved the flavor and freshness. The fish cooked evenly and had a texture you usually only find in restaurants. Delivery was punctual, and the packaging was neat and professional. I like how easy it is to keep a few fillets in the freezer for occasions like this. It makes entertaining much less stressful while still serving food that feels special and high quality.
Nathan Phillips
4/5.0
14, May 2023
Good first impression
This was my first order, and overall I?m happy. Delivery was quick, the packaging kept things frozen, and the fish tasted fresh after cooking. The salmon especially stood out. A little pricey compared to local stores, but I?d rather pay for quality. Excited to try more options.
Ronald Sanchez
4/5.0
14, May 2023
Fresh and flexible
Ordered a custom box of cod and char, great taste and clean packaging. Very happy with the flexibility to skip or adjust the next shipment. Only reason for 4 stars is that one box arrived a bit later than expected, but still fresh.
Harold Brooks
5/5.0
09, May 2023
Better than store-bought
Compared to the frozen fish I?ve tried from grocery stores, this is a huge improvement. The salmon fillets were fresh, clean, and had no off smell. Delivery was smooth, and each piece was individually sealed for convenience. I?m glad I gave this service a chance, it?s worth it.
Mason Kelly
3/5.0
22, Apr 2023
Fresh, sustainable seafood
I liked the emphasis on sustainability and antibiotic-free seafood. The cod was mild and cooked beautifully. Packaging was neat and compact. Only downside is the price, but considering the traceability and quality, it?s fair. I?ll likely continue with the subscription because the fish really does taste fresher.
Nathan Morris
4/5.0
18, Apr 2023
Fresh taste, minor delay
One delivery came a day late, but the fish was still frozen and tasted great. Salmon had nice, clean flavor. I?ll order again, but maybe keep an eye on the schedule.
Shawn Henderson
5/5.0
10, Apr 2023
Exceeded expectations
I was hesitant about ordering seafood online, but this proved me wrong. The salmon was excellent, moist, flaky, and flavorful without being overwhelming. The box arrived frozen solid, and the insulation worked perfectly. I liked how the packaging was compact, fitting easily in my freezer. What impressed me most was the sourcing transparency, I could see exactly where my fish came from. That gave me peace of mind and made me feel confident about the quality I was eating.
Megan Martin
2/5.0
05, Apr 2023
Not worth the hype
Everyone seemed to rave about this service, but my experience wasn?t great. The cod fillets were thin and dried out after cooking. Delivery came late in the evening, and I didn?t feel the product justified the cost. I?ll stick with local seafood vendors next time.
Timothy Harris
5/5.0
05, Apr 2023
Perfect portions, perfect taste
I love how each piece is individually vacuum-sealed, makes cooking for one so much easier. The Icelandic salmon arrived fresh and flavorful, and the seafood tracking was a nice touch. Great quality and a hassle-free delivery. Will definitely reorder soon.
Fish For Skeptics
Address
United States
Website
forskeptics.com
Email
Telephone
