The Tollemache Arms
3.54/5.0
Emmett Chhabra
2/5.0
06, Aug 2025
Menu overpriced for quality
Decor looked inviting but prices high for what turned up. Sandwich was dry and salad limp. Drink arrived fast though. Staff polite but seemed distracted. Good atmosphere but needs stronger cooking to match cost.
Wyatt Kulkarni
5/5.0
16, Jul 2025
Great Sunday roast
Roast dinner portions were generous and veggies well seasoned. Gravy tasted homemade. Touch of rustic charm in decor made it feel authentic. Service moved steadily?not rushed. Dessert menu offered regional treats that looked tempting. Good find for weekend dining.
Wren Diallo
2/5.0
02, Jul 2025
A bit chaotic evening
Weekend crowd brought energy but too many staff juggling orders. Plates mixed up. Ours cold. Better packing or tracking skills needed.
Milo Biswas
5/5.0
26, Jun 2025
Hidden gem for locals
Weekday evening saw many regulars, all greeting staff by name?a good sign. Server offered hidden menu snail dish, earth?flavours were good surprise. Main fish stew had herbs in broth, fresh baguette dipped perfectly. Pub interior clean, with tasteful artwork. Felt part of community even as visitor. Going back to sample desserts.
Eleanor Weber
3/5.0
08, Jun 2025
Food flavour uneven in several dishes
Pub interior looked nice and cosy. However, food quality varied: starter soup was tasty, but mains lacked seasoning. Steaks cooked too well, veal pie soggy and bland. Sides served lukewarm. Staff seemed friendly but under?trained; they mixed up half our order. Drinks took a bit to appear despite empty glasses. Noise level rose fast as pub filled?felt a bit chaotic. Restroom was clean but lacked hand cream or tissues. Good things included the dark wood decor and local beer on tap. But if culinary consistency improves, this place could become a stronger contender locally.
Isla Moreau
3/5.0
12, May 2025
Comforting place, needs flavor
Felt comfy by fireplace. Sadly main lacked punch. Tinny peas accompanied pie. Small portion. Servers attent to refills but meal missed note.
Harrison Gupta
4/5.0
05, May 2025
Lovely midweek break
Wednesday evening saw mellow setting. Friend group tried three starters and four mains. Goat cheese tart silky?creamy, sea bass cooked spot?on. Burgers held together firmly. Sides included braised cabbage with warm spices. Dessert was panna cotta, wobbly and mildly sweet. Staff described specials and ingredient sources. Wine pairing suggestion got bonus nod. Ambience relaxed, lighting dappled. Kids nearby but noise minimal. Floorboards made occasional creak but added character. Solid mid?week escape.
Violet Rossi
4/5.0
25, Apr 2025
Solid gastropub meal
Chose Tollemache for a quick pub?style dinner. Starters were crisp and mains satisfying. Staff refilled water glasses without being asked. Flooring had a tiny tilt but added local character. Reasonably priced and easygoing.
Maisie Sowah
4/5.0
15, Apr 2025
Quality gastropub visit
Menu offering seasonal specials impressed. Mushroom risotto creamy, mushrooms fresh. Parmesan dust added sharpness. Beer?battered haddock crisp with light batter. Peas were sweet and bright. Service efficient and friendly, recommending wine match. Restroom modern and clean. Slight ding from a creaky floorboard, but added charm. Recommend as a reliable pub dinner spot.
Willow Mancini
2/5.0
30, Mar 2025
Seasonal menu let down
Menu boasted seasonal specials but few live up to expectations. Brussel scrounger salad was overly acidic, mains tried trendy fusion but missed flavour balance. Tried explaining to server but they had no suggestions. Aside from food, interior charming. Would mark this one as a swing option if mains step up.
Ivy Pavlov
4/5.0
08, Mar 2025
Calm feast with care
Evening visit revealed thoughtful choices. Starters of coastal mussels in garlic broth were clean and briny, served with toasted baguette. Mains: slow?cooked shoulder of pork was threaded with herbs and melting in the mouth. Seasonal slaw offered crunch. Drinks menu well chosen with regional wines. Atmosphere: fireplace crackle, low jazz softly playing. Bathroom stocked and tidy. Staff described daily deals with knowledge. Entire meal paced perfectly?no rush, no lag. Room for minor tweaks on desserts, but overall a balanced feast in a comforting setting.
Felix Jha
3/5.0
28, Feb 2025
Decent, but service slow
Venue had local charm. Wait staff friendly. But service pace slow and spacing between courses too long. Food quality okay once arrived.
Georgia Lee
5/5.0
10, Feb 2025
Cozy pub with flavour
Tollemache Arms felt reassuringly local. Shared starter plate offered oozing brie, ham chunks, olives, balsamic drizzle. Main of venison casserole had tender meat and root veg in rich sauce. Side of buttered mash complemented. Server told us about venison sourced nearby. Drinks menu included craft cider. Background acoustic music smooth. Staff asked about food issues discreetly. We lingered over pudding?pear and almond tart with cream, subtle sweetness. All felt balanced?tasteful, regional, attentive. Enjoyable from ambiance through finish.
Finn Bhatia
5/5.0
05, Feb 2025
Family?friendly gem
Kids menu kept little ones happy. Parents enjoyed refined main plates. Staff offered colouring sheets and extra wipes. High chair stable and clean. Busiest at lunch, but ambiance stayed calm. Definitely would recommend for families.
Jude Naidu
5/5.0
21, Jan 2025
Excellent family lunch
Visited with grandparents and kids. Group seating arranged swiftly. Kids enjoyed fish fingers and fries. Adults sampled sausage roll and mash special which tasted hearty and home?made. Staff handed colouring packs to little ones. High chairs stable and clean. Outdoor benches welcomed sunny lunch. Bathrooms tidy with extra supplies. Small heartwarming moments made it stand out. Will return for another family outing.
Leo Dhawan
3/5.0
14, Jan 2025
Ambience nice but value lacking
Delightful period decor and peaceful vibe. Pricing seemed steep though, for portion sizes delivered. Starter felt under?whelming relative to cost. Mains were edible but not standout. Highlights included decor and cleanliness. Noise stayed low. Service was functional though not particularly knowledgeable. Drinks refill prompt. Might come back if menu sees more variety or deals. Not bad, yet value felt slightly off for expected local gastro?pub standard.
Audrey Rossi
2/5.0
08, Dec 2024
Bland salad too simple
Ordered fresh salad. Got wilted leaves and low?flavour dressing. Lacked texture and bite. Interiors nice, glassware clean.
Aurora Jensen
2/5.0
15, Nov 2024
Drinks service needs work
Environment comfortable, but drinks service lagged badly. After ordering three ales and two juices, waited over fifteen minutes for anything to arrive. Glasses appeared sticky. Staff apologized but seemed overwhelmed. When they finally came, glasses weren?t chilled properly. Tried flagging again for another round but the pub shifted focus elsewhere. There?s charm here, but bar staffing and bar speed need serious improvement. Returned main course hot, but the wait overshadowed it. Intend to try again?but only if reservations made and straightforward orders placed.
Finnigan Moreau
4/5.0
04, Nov 2024
Rich Sunday roast setting
Typical Sunday found the pub packed but staff kept order. Roast beef sliced thin, pink and tender. Yorkshire puddings soft and eggy. Seasonal veg bright and peas fresh. Gravy depth impressive. Starter of soup tasted house?made. Pudding of sticky toffee calm and creamy. Ale tap offered local brew. Decor: original fireplace and cane seats. Service punctual and room cleared between courses. Tried their dessert?wine pairing recommendation?nice but pricey. All in all a solid roast experience in a stylish environment.
Declan Pathak
2/5.0
17, Oct 2024
Slow starters, average main
Starter took ages to appear. By time of mains patience ran low. Steak arrived tough. Mix?up with side order. Server apologetic but limited solution.
Alice Pavlov
4/5.0
22, Sep 2024
Friendly pub experience
Staff greeted us on arrival and showed us to our table. Offerings covered typical pub classics and a few seasonal specials that sounded tasty. Drinks arrived promptly. Flooring was a bit creaky but added character. Overall a pleasant, relaxed evening worth repeating soon.
Eliza Mancini
4/5.0
21, Aug 2024
Thoughtful food, calm vibe
Quiet evening visit revealed thoughtful menu. Goat cheese salad came with seasonal fruit and light dressing. Main of pork belly nicely crisped. Mashed potato well creamy. Server described origins of local ingredients. Bathroom stocked nicely. Would enjoy sitting by fireplace next time.
Clara Silva
3/5.0
10, Aug 2024
Just ok visit
Pub looked welcoming. Burger tasted fine but pattie was slightly overdone for my taste. Chips could?ve been crispier. Service was polite but slow between courses. Might still give it another try when it?s quieter.
Sylvie Weber
4/5.0
16, Jul 2024
Comfortable dinner outing
Tollemache Arms welcomes with warmth. Leather seats and fireplace add to charm. Grilled fish main was fresh and flaky. Sides were creative?courgette ribbons with lemon drizzle. Dessert of lemon tart was zesty and light. Staff explained daily specials knowledgeably. Price slightly higher than average pub, but value felt fair. Will recommend to friends seeking a calm dinner spot.
Sadie Schmidt
1/5.0
29, Jun 2024
Not impressed with desserts
Puds menu sounded fun?sticky toffee, local ice?cream. But desserts tasted overly sweet and generic. Topping overpowered base. Dessert spoon had sugar granules left behind. Took more sugar than flavour. Service polite, but over?sweet ending left little positive taste. Sure hope they test balance better next seasons.
Hayden Iyer
4/5.0
07, Jun 2024
Excellent pub dinner outing
Group of four visited early Saturday. Starters arrived promptly?fresh bruschetta and cheese sticks. Mains: slow braised beef brisket fell apart; chicken skewers smokey and juicy. Shared rosemary roasters were crisp. Portions filled plates but didn?t overwhelm. Staff guided wine picks. Clean bathroom and accessible layout. Noise remained friendly?lively. Everything ran smoothly?timing, taste, atmosphere. Was a nice treat night without pomp.
Hugo Luthra
5/5.0
23, Apr 2024
Detailed dining delight
First impression: cosy beams, polished floors, mellow lighting. Ordered sharing board?cured meats, local cheese, house?pickles, crunchy bread?excellent textures and tastes. Main of confit duck leg coated in crispy skin, tender inside, served with root?veg mash. Sage jus tied flavours together. Sides included fine green beans and glazed carrots. Dessert of spiced apple crumble-fancy warm, slightly tart topping, ice?cream side. Staff genuine?took care to explain sourcing and cooking. Manager checked table personally. Portions hearty but not overwhelming. Even restroom had local art and scented soap. A full evening that felt well curated from start to finish. Places like this make local pub?food feel top notch.
Jasper Ahuja
2/5.0
09, Apr 2024
Service took its sweet time
Staff showed willingness to help yet took too long to take orders. Wait stretched past comfortable levels. Food arrived lukewarm, missing some crispness expected. Requested ketchup twice before it arrived. Atmosphere lukewarm too?lights a bit dim. Tried to flag refills but server acted like they were rushed off their feet. The menu sounded promising on paper, but execution fell short. The pub?s character still came through in antique fittings and wooden beams, though that charm didn?t quite outshine the service drawbacks. If attention to timing and temperature improves, this place could shine. As it stands, visit felt slower and less polished than hoped for a weekday evening.
August Sundaram
3/5.0
05, Mar 2024
Pub needed more light
Rustic pub feel nice. But lighting too dim near window seats. Food was okay, prices moderate. Servers checked in just once.
Silas Goel
1/5.0
21, Feb 2024
Dog?friendly but unprepared
Dog?friendly pub seemed fun, but staff didn?t offer water bowl or settle area for our dog. Couldn?t place dog safely. Dog menu nonexistent. Food for humans was average?nothing memorable. Cleanliness was acceptable but dog traces around tables. Felt they weren?t actually set up to welcome pets properly. If aiming for pet?friendly, could improve signage and supplies. Otherwise nice location and seating.
Gwyneth Ndlovu
5/5.0
02, Feb 2024
Stylish community pub dinner
Local pub with dark timber and subtle lighting. Shared small plates: smoked salmon p?t?, crunchy crostini, warm olives. Guests chatted across tables pleasantly. Main of lamb burger topped with halloumi on brioche bun?juicy with tang. Fries thick?cut and well?seasoned. Server suggested local lager that matched burger?s richness. Pre?booking recommended as tables fill fast. Conversation felt genuine. Weekly events board showed quiz night coming. Bathroom had fresh hand?towels and fragrance. Balanced experience?food, drink, community all aligned.
Calvin Soni
5/5.0
29, Jan 2024
Lovely date venue
Charming low?lit tables and fireside seating created intimate vibe. Chicken breast entr?e was moist; roast garlic sauce was the highlight. Charcuterie wrapped board for two added variety. Cocktails had fresh herbs garnish. Conversation with staff felt easy and unforced. Quiet and attentive ambiance made it ideal for conversation. A calm, caring gem in local pub scene.
Asher Majumdar
5/5.0
09, Jan 2024
Charming local spot
Quaint spot with period features and friendly staff. Real ales on tap tasted smooth. Planner review special had inventive ingredients. Wait staff attentive without hovering. Wished there was more outdoor seating but interior charm makes up for it.
Lucy Diallo
4/5.0
19, Dec 2023
Local favourite
Seems popular with locals, filling up early evening. Ale selection felt thoughtful. Chosen pie was warm and hearty. Puds section looked good. Bathroom tidy. Might return to sample the seasonal specials next time.
Beatrice Schmidt
4/5.0
11, Dec 2023
Rich flavours, polite staff
Date night menu included venison burger. Rich but not overly heavy. Port jus sauce added depth. Sweet potato fries crisp. Server offered wine pairing suggestion. Served at leisurely pace that suited us. Overall well?paced and relaxing pub dinner.
Hailey Kowalski
5/5.0
25, Nov 2023
Warm welcome plus great food
Arrival greeted by friendly host. Menu featured refreshed classics?veal schnitzel, beef pie, fish?and?chips?all looked appealing. Chosen schnitzel crisp and golden, lemon wedge squeezed freshness. Pea pur?e smooth. Pint poured cleanly, cool. Staff checked in twice during meal. Dessert recommendation: baked cheesecake with berry coulis, tangy and not overly sweet. Seating layout avoided bumping elbows. Background music low and tasteful. Felt attentive without show. Confidently good local pub dinner for food lovers and casual diners.
Henry Balakrishnan
3/5.0
01, Nov 2023
Creative menu, flawed delivery
Interesting food ideas like curried mushrooms and local cheese board. Sadly presentation sloppy?mushy mushrooms mixed into overbaked puff. Cheese board missing fruit garnish. Wine list small but adequate. Staff honest about missing an item. Error didn?t kill mood entirely, but execution needs polish. Could be great with more consistent kitchen staff training.
Freya Jensen
4/5.0
27, Oct 2023
Great ale & food pairing
Enjoyed locally sourced ale paired with pie special?a buttery crust enclosing savoury filling. Side of minted peas gave freshness. Server suggested pairing based on flavor profile. Decor includes vintage mirrors and exposed brick. Music in background set relaxed, not overbearing mood. Later spotted chef chatting with customers. Genuine atmosphere and solid pub fare.
Nora Moreau
4/5.0
14, Oct 2023
Relaxed midweek dinner
Place had a peaceful vibe mid?week. Seating was comfy, lighting soft. Main dishes came hot and well?presented. Side salad was fresh and crisp. Prices seemed fair given portion size. A nice option for casual dinner.
June Silva
2/5.0
30, Sep 2023
Underwhelming vegan option
Broccoli steak vegan main looked pretty but tasted bland. Lentil mix under seasoned. Nice try, just missed the mark.
Derek Campbell
5/5.0
16, Sep 2023
Perfect family celebration
Mom?s birthday celebrated here. Prior to visit, discussed allergy for mother?staff confirmed safe dishes. Arrival: table decorated with flowers, no surcharge. Shared starters included hummus platter and crispy calamari?both well balanced. My main, haddock fillet, was flaky with fresh herbs; partner?s steak cooked to order. Kids got hot dog and mash?pizza?like quality. Staff entertained children kindly. Cake presented with candle. Warm lighting and wood seats held cosy tone. Sipped pint and soft drinks calmly. Felt special without fuss. Coordinates well for small family parties. Highly caring staff and kitchen followed through consistently.
Theodore Abraham
1/5.0
04, Sep 2023
Meat wasn?t fresh tasting
The Tollemache Arms has inviting beams and nice lighting, but everything soured when food arrived tasting stale. Meat smelled faintly off, and gravy left a weird aftertaste. Staff apologies didn?t reduce the worry about food prep. Not something expected at pub standards. Asked for removal of the plate, but resolution slow. Felt uneasy about hygiene. Didn?t stay for dessert or drinks. Left early to eat elsewhere. Hope this points them to review kitchen procedures and stock rotation.
Sawyer Ganesan
1/5.0
17, Aug 2023
Noisy night, poor service
Saturday buzz turned into loud chaos. Server forgot order. Drinks mixed wrong. Food had errors. Gave up on second course.
Graham Joshi
4/5.0
23, Jul 2023
Sophisticated casual supper
Evening visit for casual meal. Starters light: beetroot carpaccio, fresh goat cheese, micro herbs. Mains: pan?seared sea bass crisped skin, soft flesh, served on pea pur?e. Sides of rosemary potatoes roasted nicely. Dessert of chocolate fondant locked in deep taste. Drinks recommendation showed staff confidence. Pub interior simple but elegant?whitewashed walls and wooden tables. Clean floors and bathrooms too. Pace was smooth between courses. Couldn?t name any flaw. A calm, refined step above usual pub meals.
Penelope Sowah
2/5.0
12, Jul 2023
Long wait despite emptiness
We wandered in on a quiet Thursday, tables mostly empty. Despite this, no one greeted us for ten minutes. Finally seated, but slow service persisted?took an age to place a drink order. Food arrived coldish, despite being the only table with mains. Staff apologized, but explanation vague. Felt overlooked completely. Decor and seating are nice though. Might shine with more staff training or better roster clarity.
Oscar Khanna
5/5.0
25, Jun 2023
Warm evening gathering
Celebrated friend?s birthday here. Staff arranged chairs and table neatly. Group ordered wings share and steak plates. All food came hot and tastes varied well. Local cider choices impressed. Staff brought candle?lit pud plate. Atmosphere cozy, with smooth music in background. Everyone remarked they felt comfortable and relaxed. A pub that understands small group events.
Milo Mehra
5/5.0
03, Jun 2023
Memorable date night
Lovely wood beams created a romantic feel. Food flavours balanced nicely. Cocktails came with fresh garnishes. Server offered helpful pairing suggestions. Quiet corner booth was ideal for conversation. A calm place for a nice night out.
Nathan Verma
5/5.0
19, May 2023
Cosy evening out
Atmosphere felt warm and friendly, perfect for an evening gather. Food was well?cooked, with flavours that hit the mark. Staff checked in just the right amount without being intrusive. Seemed well?managed and clean. Will likely come back on a colder night for a nice roast.
Otis Kapur
5/5.0
06, May 2023
Rustic charm with solid food
Period beams and wood paneling set a cosy scene. Shared starter platter was varied: charcuterie, olives, cheeses?all fresh and flavourful. My main, lamb shank, fell off the bone and paired nicely with mash and seasonal veg. Local ale complemented well. Service friendly, checked in frequently without being intrusive. Holistically felt well planned?from the curated menu to ambiance. A pub where all elements align to create a pleasant evening. Will bring guests next time.
Josie Pavlov
3/5.0
22, Apr 2023
Rocking beams, shaky food
Period looks held charm but meal didn?t impress. Chicken overdone, gravy bland. Chips soggy. Staff offered replacement but it also underwhelmed. Was pleasant spot though.
The Tollemache Arms
Address
NA
Website
tollemacheharrington.com
Email
Telephone
